Tag Archives: English as a Medium of Instruction

English as a Medium of Instruction in Nepal: A Critical Review of Dr. Prem Phyak’s Interview, Shiksha Bimarsha: Angreji Madhyam Ra Yasle Shikshan Sikaima Pareko Prabhav

           Khem Raj Rauteda

Abstract

The growing adoption of English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) in Nepal has generated extensive debate regarding its educational, linguistic, and social implications. This paper critically reviews the interview शिक्षा विमर्श : अंग्रेजी माध्यम र यसले शिक्षण सिकाइमा पार्ने प्रभाव | Interview with Prem Fhyak – YouTube featuring Dr. Prem Phyak, which examines the emergence of EMI, the ideologies supporting its implementation, and its consequences for teaching and learning in Nepal’s multilingual context. The review summarizes the key arguments presented in the interview and critically analyzes them through relevant educational, sociolinguistic, and philosophical perspectives. It discusses concerns related to language policy, learners’ comprehension, identity, educational equity, and the gap between policy and classroom practice. The paper further examines the interview through decolonial theory, critical pedagogy, Marxist perspectives, and multilingual approaches to understand the broader implications of EMI for language, power, and social justice. Particular attention is given to the advocacy of mother tongue-based multilingual education and translanguaging as pedagogical alternatives that recognize learners’ linguistic resources and promote more inclusive learning environments. The review concludes that the interview provides a timely and thought-provoking critique of EMI in Nepal and highlights the need for language policies and educational practices that are responsive to the country’s multilingual realities and committed to educational equity.

Keywords: English as a Medium of Instruction, multilingual education, language policy, translanguaging, Nepal, critical review

Introduction

The increasing adoption of English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) has become one of the most debated issues in Nepalese education. While EMI is often associated with educational quality, global competitiveness, and social mobility, it has also generated concerns regarding learners’ comprehension, linguistic rights, educational equity, and the role of local languages in multilingual classrooms (Rauteda, 2024a; Rauteda & Luitel, 2025). These debates have drawn the attention of scholars, educators, and policymakers who continue to question the appropriateness and consequences of EMI in Nepal’s linguistically diverse context.

Against this backdrop, this paper critically reviews the interview titled Shiksha Bimarsha: Angreji Madhyam ra Yasle Shikshan Sikaima Pareko Prabhav, published on the ‘Nepalkhabar YouTube channel’ on 30 May 2024. The interview, conducted by Roshna Subba with Dr. Prem Phyak, Associate Professor at Columbia University, New York, and former Head of the Department of English Education at Tribhuvan University, discusses the historical development of EMI, the ideologies underpinning its implementation, its practices in Nepal, and the relevance of multilingual education in addressing the country’s linguistic diversity.

The purpose of this review is to critically examine the major arguments presented in the interview by situating them within relevant educational, sociolinguistic, and philosophical perspectives. In doing so, the paper highlights the implications of EMI for teaching, learning, language policy, and educational justice while discussing the potential of Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) and translanguaging as alternative pedagogical approaches in Nepalese classrooms.

Overview of the Interview

The interview primarily discusses the implications of EMI in the Nepalese education system, with particular attention to its relevance in a multilingual society (Phyak, 2021; 2023). At the outset, Dr. Prem Phyak argues that teaching children through a language unfamiliar to them creates barriers to meaningful learning, as learners are unable to express themselves freely in their native languages (Phyak, 2021). He emphasizes that language plays a fundamental role in children’s learning and identity formation, particularly at the primary level (Phyak, 2023).

The discussion traces the historical emergence and expansion of EMI in both global and Nepalese contexts and examines the major ideologies that have supported its adoption. It explores the reasons behind the increasing implementation of EMI in Nepal, including assumptions regarding educational quality, competitiveness, and social aspirations. The interview also highlights the discrepancy between language policy and classroom practice, questioning the effectiveness of EMI in multilingual classrooms where learners and teachers possess diverse linguistic backgrounds.

A substantial part of the interview focuses on the educational, social, and linguistic implications of EMI. Dr. Phyak argues that the widespread use of English as the sole medium of instruction may limit learner participation, reduce opportunities for meaningful classroom interaction, and marginalize learners’ home languages. This idea of Dr. Phyak has also been advocated in his own empirical studies, such as (Phyak, 2021; 2023), and in some other scholars’ works, such as (Rauteda, 2024a; Rauteda & Luitel, 2025). The discussion further addresses the symbolic value of English in Nepalese society and its influence on educational practices and language ideologies.

The interview concludes by advocating MTB-MLE as a more appropriate approach for Nepal’s multilingual context. It also introduces multilingual pedagogical practices, particularly translanguaging, as a means of utilizing learners’ full linguistic repertoires to support teaching and learning. Throughout the discussion, the interview emphasizes the importance of developing language policies and classroom practices that are responsive to Nepal’s linguistic diversity and educational realities.

Critical Analysis of the Interview

In the interview, Phyak contended that language-related issues have not been adequately addressed in Nepal. Current language policies and educational language planning fail to reflect the country’s multilingual context, where 124 languages are spoken (NSO, 2021). Phyak emphasized the significance of language in learning, particularly at the foundational levels, advocating for mother tongue-based multilingual education (MTB-MLE). Such an approach fosters an open and supportive environment that encourages learners to become critical, creative, and innovative thinkers. He further argued that teaching in a language other than the learners’ mother tongue imposes a cognitive burden, diminishing learner engagement. Supporting his argument, Rauteda (2025a) states that teaching solely using the English language in the classroom, avoiding learners’ home languages, creates disengagement and demotivation. Although English is frequently used as the medium of instruction in Nepal’s educational system, this practice restricts learners’ potential and overlooks transformative aspects of education. Phyak also highlighted the importance of multilingual education for facilitating interaction, encouraging inquiry, and promoting social transformation and justice.

Referencing neurological linguistics and research on language teaching and learning, the speaker advocated for MTB-MLE, arguing that EMI restricts children’s potential. The speaker emphasized the social, cultural, political, and economic challenges created by using a foreign language as the medium of instruction. A key point raised was that fostering a sense of belonging is crucial for effective learning, which is achievable only when children are taught in their mother tongue. In this regard, Rauteda (2025a) says that learners’ sense of belonging can only be assured when their linguistic repertoire is allowed to be used in the classrooms. Furthermore, the speaker argued that language is intrinsically linked to identity, and children may experience a loss of safety and pride if they are not exposed to their family language. Thus, MTB-MLE is framed as a decolonial practice, challenging monolingual ideologies. The speaker also drew upon Foucault’s ideas of language and power, linking them to educational language planning and policy, where only so-called standard languages hold dominance, while others are marginalized. Additionally, language was portrayed as a tool that can perpetuate the colonization of other languages, cultures, and systems over time.

The interviewer then raised a question regarding the EMI context, to which Dr. Phyak responded by contextualizing EMI, echoing Dearden’s (2014) perspective. He explained that EMI refers to a situation where English is not spoken at home, nor in the neighborhood, with siblings, nor used as a contact language. However, content subjects such as science, mathematics, and other disciplinary areas are taught in English. Dr. Phyak further expanded on the broader discourse in language teaching, distinguishing between ‘learning a language’ and ‘learning through a language,’ emphasizing that these are fundamentally different processes.

The speaker highlighted several hegemonic aspects of EMI, using examples such as the designation of ‘English Speaking Zones’ in private school settings. This linguistic landscape, according to the speaker, is indicative of the presence of English imperialism within the medium of instruction. Addressing different EMI contexts, the speaker noted that in some schools where EMI is implemented alongside other languages, hierarchical structures have emerged. These practices, the speaker argued, have exacerbated inequalities and perpetuated injustice in educational environments, widening the gap between elites and ordinary citizens. Drawing on Marx’s concept of class, the speaker suggested that EMI has created class distinctions in schools, with English being associated with the elite. Additionally, research has shown that English is viewed as a language of power, prestige, and social capital, resonating with Bourdieu’s (1986) notion of linguistic capital.

Phyak explained that the adoption of EMI initially began in private schools and was later extended to public schools in the name of enhancing quality education and fostering competition. The discussion further explored the underlying ideologies supporting EMI, including the aims of increasing student enrollment, fulfilling parental aspirations, improving educational quality, and promoting internationalization (Rauteda, 2024a). However, Phyak expressed his dissent regarding these ideologies, arguing that they are based on misconceptions and misunderstandings. Additionally, the discussion revealed that many schools abandoned EMI after failing to achieve the anticipated outcomes.

Phyak highlighted a significant issue with the implementation of EMI, pointing out the paradox that stakeholders are unable to provide a sufficient number of English subject teachers while expecting all subjects to be taught in English. He argued that this discrepancy reveals a critical problem, particularly at the primary level, where subject-specific teachers are in short supply. Phyak emphasized that the low proficiency of teachers in English exacerbates the challenges of EMI. He asserted that EMI impedes both student learning and teacher effectiveness, limiting educational outcomes and stifling students’ critical thinking and creativity. Furthermore, Phyak argued that EMI hampers the construction of knowledge, rendering students’ passive and diminishing their capacity for critical analysis.

The speaker contended that learning extends beyond merely passing exams and understanding the prescribed curriculum; it involves applying knowledge to solve real-life problems and connecting with the community. He argued that learning English should not be viewed as an end in itself, but rather as a means to acquire skills and create space for further learning, provided that teachers deliver effective compulsory English instruction. Phyak cited reports from UNESCO, the British Council, and the World Bank, noting that approximately 37-40 percent of students show low achievement in learning due to the medium of instruction. He also addressed the belief held by some schools and stakeholders that studying in the Nepali medium undermines the strength of learners, schools, and institutions. Phyak critiqued this view as a deficit ideology towards Nepali medium education.

The speaker argued that public schools have not critically examined the situation; instead, they have accepted the policy at face value. He further stated that the preparation at the policy level is insufficient for effectively implementing EMI. Additionally, he pointed out that stakeholders are not taking the social, political, and economic impacts of the policy. Interestingly, the speaker considers this policy to be a form of educational waste, as learners struggle to grasp the intended material because of the EMI. He suggests that this issue arises from the symbolic value of the English language in social, political, and economic contexts.

Phyak seems to be positioning himself as a decolonial thinker and suggests being separated from the EMI, saying not to be bound with the language. He asked for a safe environment where the subject position of the learners is to be respected and addressed.  Showing the gap in policy and practice, he said that we are in ‘hauguji’ (imagined fear) in languaging. Moreover, the speaker said that the policy-makers are not serious about the classes that the policy has created in the schools and the community. Appealing for multilingual education, he said that multilingualism has been taken as a problem in the Nepalese schools, but it is a resource and should be utilized as an asset in the multilingual classroom for justice in diversity. The idea regarding multilingualism as a resource has been empirically justified by some studies, such as (Phyak, 2018; Rauteda, 2022; Rauteda, 2024b; Rauteda, 2025a; Rauteda, 2025b; Rauteda, 2026a). Moreover, he presented the idea that students are not the deficit object. Instead, they can perform well if they get the chance to be exposed in their mother tongue. Further, multilingual pedagogical activities are to be employed in the classroom for the cognitive, metacognitive, and metalinguistic abilities. He gave one example of multilingual pedagogical activities, i.e., ‘translanguaging’ where speakers can receive information in one language and produce in another language (Williams, 2002), and use more than two language abilities simultaneously, naturally, dynamically, and purposefully (Garcia, 2009; Phyak, 2018; Rauteda, 2022; Rauteda, 2024b). To the community of practice, Phyak suggested that teachers should have critical multilingual awareness, where empowerment of the learners is to be the central concern. So, the policy makers and practitioners should be critically aware of the ground reality of the society, thinking about the long-term effects of any policy.

Philosophical and Theoretical Stances on the Interview

The talk has been critically analyzed from different lenses or philosophical perspectives. Hence, I attempted to see the ideas based on the following philosophical views;

Decolonial Perspectives and Language Ideologies

In the interview, Phyak argues that EMI perpetuates educational and social inequalities in Nepal, an assertion that aligns closely with decolonial frameworks. This perspective reflects the foundational work of decolonial scholars such as Ngũgĩ (1986), who contends that language is not merely a communicative tool but a primary vehicle for culture, identity, and institutional power. Framed through this lens, Phyak’s interview narrative positions EMI as a continuation of colonial practices, wherein English—historically an instrument of imperial domination—has been repurposed as a contemporary marker of elitism and socio-economic privilege. Furthermore, Phyak’s call during the interview to resist dominant monolingual ideologies that marginalize local languages represents a direct challenge to the preservation of these historical power asymmetries in education (Phyak, 2021). This critique intersects with Foucault’s (1980) theorization of discourse, which demonstrates how language and knowledge function as regulatory instruments of institutional power and social control. By advocating for MTB-MLE throughout the interview, Phyak proposes a decolonial approach to schooling that actively critiques the hegemony of Western linguistic and knowledge systems. Because language policy dictates who holds the authority to speak and in what manner, it functions as a mechanism of social exclusion (Foucault, 1980). Ultimately, Phyak’s interview characterization of EMI as a catalyst for compounding social, cultural, and political challenges underscores how macro-level language policies can inadvertently reinforce elite dominance over marginalized populations (Phyak, 2023).

Critical Pedagogy and Social Justice

Phyak’s interview reflections align closely with Paulo Freire’s (1970) framework of critical pedagogy, which positions education as a mechanism for empowering marginalized populations and advancing social justice. Freire’s (1970) conceptualization of “banking education”—wherein students serve as passive recipients of top-down knowledge—parallels Phyak’s critique of EMI, which he argues imposes severe cognitive and participatory barriers on learners. According to the interview narrative, the systemic exclusion of mother-tongue instruction, particularly in primary schooling, inherently obstructs students’ capacity for critical engagement, constrains their creative agency, and ultimately reinforces existing social hierarchies (Phyak, 2023). Furthermore, Phyak’s discussion of the marginalization of Nepal’s indigenous languages through EMI exemplifies the dynamics of symbolic violence, a concept established by Pierre Bourdieu (1991). Central to this analysis is Bourdieu’s (1991) notion of “linguistic capital.” In the interview, Phyak illustrates how English functions as a dominant linguistic market asset, granting access to institutional power, prestige, and upward socio-economic mobility within Nepalese society. However, as Phyak underscores, this reliance on EMI compounds class distinctions; it systematically privileges affluent demographics with the resources to navigate elite educational spaces, while structurally marginalizing students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds who remain reliant on their primary indigenous languages (Phyak, 2021).

Marxist Class Analysis

Phyak’s observation during the interview that EMI constructs distinct “classes within schools” aligns closely with Marxist frameworks of class struggle. Within a Marxist paradigm, institutional mechanisms—including language policies—frequently function as instruments of the ruling class to regulate access to economic, social, and political resources (Marx & Engels, 1970). By prioritizing English, the Nepalese educational system entrenches a systemic class stratification; socio-economic elites with the means to access high-quality English education consolidate their structural power, while ordinary citizens are left structurally disadvantaged (Phyak, 2023). This stratification connects directly with Gramsci’s (1971) formulation of cultural hegemony, which posits that a dominant class maintains control not merely through coercive material force, but through ideological apparatuses, including formal schooling. According to the interview narrative, the pervasive emphasis on EMI across both public and private educational sectors perpetuates this hegemonic control. Phyak argues that by positioning English as the exclusive language of modern success, the state effectively manufactures consent for a system that marginalizes indigenous languages and devalues local epistemic frameworks (Phyak, 2021).

Multilingualism and Translanguaging as Resistance

Phyak’s advocacy for multilingualism, particularly his reference to translanguaging (Garcia, 2009; Williams, 2002), offers a way to resist linguistic and cultural domination. Translanguaging challenges the traditional boundaries between languages, allowing for a more fluid and dynamic use of multiple languages in the classroom (Garcia & Wei, 2014). This pedagogical practice reflects a decolonial approach, as it legitimizes the use of local languages in education, promoting equity and cognitive development. By encouraging the use of students’ full linguistic repertoire, translanguaging fosters a more inclusive and empowering learning environment, countering the monolingual dominance of EMI (Rauteda, 2025a; Rauteda, 2026b). Phyak’s emphasis on critical multilingual awareness also connects to the work of critical sociolinguists, who argue that language practices in education should reflect the multilingual realities of students’ lives (Makoni & Pennycook, 2007). The imposition of a single language of instruction, such as English, not only erases linguistic diversity but also denies students the cognitive and cultural resources embedded in their native languages.

Conclusion

This critical review of Dr. Prem Phyak’s interview illuminates the deep-seated ideological, socio-economic, and pedagogical contradictions underpinning the uncritical expansion of EMI in Nepal. Far from being a neutral vehicle for global competitiveness or educational quality, EMI functions as a structural mechanism that reproduces systemic inequalities. When evaluated through decolonial, Marxist, and critical pedagogical lenses, the pervasive imposition of English-only policies operates as an apparatus of cultural hegemony and symbolic violence. It alienates learners from their primary linguistic identities, strips them of their creative agency by enforcing a restrictive form of ‘banking education’, and entrenches deep class stratifications within the Nepalese educational landscape. Conversely, Phyak’s advocacy for MTB-MLE and translanguaging offers a transformative, decolonial pathway forward. By dismantling monolingual biases and re-centering the classroom around the child’s native linguistic repertoire, these approaches re-conceptualize multilingualism as an invaluable educational resource rather than a systemic deficit. Implementing these pluralistic pedagogical frameworks allows schools to foster genuine cognitive development, preserve indigenous cultural heritages, and promote democratic participation.

Ultimately, this review underscores that the current disconnect between top-down language planning and classroom realities cannot be resolved by superficial policy mandates. Instead, it requires a radical shift toward critical multilingual awareness among policymakers, educators, and local communities. For Nepal to achieve genuine educational equity and social justice, its schooling systems must divest from the homogenizing forces of linguistic imperialism and actively embrace policies that are authentically responsive to the country’s rich, historical multilingual realities.

The author:

Khem Raj Rauteda is an ELT researcher, teacher, and teacher educator currently pursuing his M.Phil. at the Graduate School of Education, Tribhuvan University. He is also a Lecturer at Janta Multiple Campus, Itahari, Sunsari.

Email: krauteda@gmail.com
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5869-7304

References

Bourdieu, P. (1986). The Forms of Capital. In J. Richardson (Ed.), Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education (pp. 241–258). Greenwood.

Bourdieu, P. (1991). Language and symbolic power (G. Raymond & M. Adamson, Trans.; J. B. Thompson, Ed.). Harvard University Press.

Dearden, J. (2014). English as a Medium of Instruction – A Growing Global Phenomenon. British Council.

Foucault, M. (1972). The Archaeology of Knowledge. Pantheon Books.

Foucault, M. (1980). Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977. Pantheon Books.

Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Herder and Herder.

Garcia, O. & Wei, L. (2014). Translanguaging: Language, bilingualism and education. Palgrave.

Garcia, O. (2009). Bilingual Education in the 21st Century: A Global Perspective. Wiley-Blackwell.

Gramsci, A. (1971). Selections from the prison notebooks (Q. Hoare & G. N. Smith, Eds. & Trans.). International Publishers.

Makoni, S., & Pennycook, A. (2007). Disinventing and Reconstituting Languages. Multilingual Matters.

Marx, K., & Engels, F. (1970). The German ideology (C. J. Arthur, Ed.). International Publishers.

National Statistics Office. (2021). National population and housing census 2021 results. Government of Nepal.

Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o. (1986). Decolonising the Mind: The Politics of Language in African Literature. Heinemann Educational.

Phyak, P. (2021). Language education policy in Nepal and the denial of the right to speak in Indigenous languages. Melbourne Asia Review, 7. https://doi.org/10.37839/mar2652-550×7.7

Phyak, P. (2023). Producing the disciplined English-speaking subjects: Language policing, development ideology, and English medium of instruction policy. Language in Society, 53(2), 321–343. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0047404523000052

Rauteda, K. (2026b). Translanguaging in English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) content classrooms: Unfolding the teachers’ narratives. IJIET (International Journal of Indonesian Education and Teaching), 10(2), 200-216. https://doi.org/10.24071/ijiet.v10i2.14291

Rauteda, K. R. (2022). Translanguaging as a pedagogical resource in multilingual ELT classrooms: Exploring perceptions and practices [Master’s Thesis]. Tribhuvan University.

Rauteda, K. R. (2024a). Use of EMI at secondary education: Exploring non-English Nepalese teachers’ ideologies. Siddhajyoti Interdisciplinary Journal, 5(1), 33-43. https://doi.org/10.3126/sij.v5i1.63596

Rauteda, K. R. (2024b). Unveiling pedagogical translanguaging: Investigating teachers’ translingual practices and purposes in ELT classrooms. English Language Teaching Perspectives, 9(1-2), 51–66. https://doi.org/10.3126/eltp.v9i1-2.68719

Rauteda, K. R. (2025a). Translanguaging for transformation: Identity, equity, and pedagogical resistance in Nepalese ELT classrooms. Indonesian Journal of English Language Studies (IJELS), 11(2), 150-162. https://doi.org/10.24071/ijels.v11i2.12202

Rauteda, K. R. (2026a). Linguistic hybridity in Nepalese ELT classrooms: A narrative inquiry into English language teachers’ beliefs and practices. Journal of Janta Multiple Campus, 5(1), 147-170. https://doi.org/10.3126/jjmc.v5i1.97994

Rauteda, K. R., & Luitel, B. (2025). Teachers’ pedagogical resistance of EMI through classroom translanguaging in Nepalese science classrooms. IJIET (International Journal of Indonesian Education and Teaching), 9(2), 441-456. https://doi.org/10.24071/ijiet.v9i2.12043

Rauteda, K.R. (2025b). Enhancing Learner Engagement through Translanguaging Pedagogy: A Reflective Narrative from a Multilingual ELT Classroom in Nepal [Blog article]. ELT Choutari. Available at: https://eltchoutari.com/2025/11/enhancing-learner-engagement-throughtranslanguaging-pedagogy-a-reflective-narrative-from-a-multilingual-eltclassroom-in-nepal/

Williams, C. (2002). Extending Bilingualism in the Education System.

Book Review: Teaching English as an International Language

Mr. Nar Bahadur Bist

Title: Teaching English as an International Language
Authors: Ali Fuad Selvi, Nicola Galloway
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Publication Year: First published online: December 2023
ISBN:  9781009462495 (HB), 9781108821230 (PB), 9781108902755 (OC) ISSNs: 2632-4415 (online), 2632-4407 (print)

Introduction

Teaching English as an International Language by Ali Fuad Selvi and Nicola Galloway is a comprehensive examination of the expanding role of English in the world. As English increasingly functions as a global lingua franca, this book explores the implications for teaching and learning the language. As English increasingly functions as a global lingua franca, it has significant implications for teaching and learning across diverse sociocultural contexts (Selvi & Galloway, 2023; Jenkins, 2007). Moreover, it explores the evolving role of English as a global language and the implications for teaching English as an international language. It provides a comprehensive overview of key themes and practical strategies for effective English instruction. The objectives are to equip teachers with knowledge and skills to navigate the complexities of teaching English internationally. Mainly, the approaches are blend of theoretical, empirical, and practical perspectives to bridge research and classroom practice. The theme of the article is Globalization of English, cultural diversity, intercultural competence, teacher education. English as a Global Language English, has become the predominant language of international communication, business, and academia. English is used in a wide range of contexts, from formal to informal, across diverse cultures. It has role and status of English continues to evolve, with increased linguistic diversity and transfer in the linguistic power.

Content Synopsis

The subject matter of this book offers a comprehensive account of the unprecedented spread of English as a global language by taking historical, sociolinguistic, and pedagogical perspectives. To realize this main objective, it opens with an accessible discussion of the historical path of the English language. The book integrates historical, sociolinguistic, and pedagogical perspectives to examine English as a global and multilingual lingua franca (Selvi & Galloway, 2023; Matsuda, 2012). Besides that, the qualitative and quantitative connections to its contemporary diversity in terms of forms, roles, functions, uses, users, and contexts of English as a global and multilingual Franca.  Built upon this synchronic-diachronic symbiosis, the discussion is complemented by an overview of major analytical paradigms and trends that promote systematical scrutiny of the English language and its sociolinguistic and educational implications. It ends by showcasing instructional practices, recommendations, reflective questions, and future directions for language educators to revamp their beliefs, commitments, and practices considering the changing needs and realities of the present-day global sociolinguistic ecology and individuals therein. The book is divided into several chapters, each addressing different aspects of teaching English as an international language (EIL).

Key Topics in the Book

The key topics included in the book are presented under the following headings.

The Global Spread of English

This chapter merely the historical and contemporary spread of English around the world.  The role and status of English continue to evolve with increased linguistic diversity and shifting power relations (Kachru, 1992; Kirkpatrick, 2010).Furthermore, highlighting its status as an international language. English is used in a wide range of contexts, from formal to informal, across diverse cultures.

Theoretical Frameworks

The authors investigate into various theoretical frameworks that inform English as a International Language. The theoretical frameworks such as World Englishes and English as a Lingua Franca to challenge native-speaker norms in English language teaching (Jenkins, 2007; Kachru, 1992). It involves teaching, such as World Englishes, English as a Lingua Franca (ELF), and trans-languaging.

Curriculum and Pedagogy

Practical strategies for designing curriculum and classroom activities that reflect the global nature of English are presented. This includes integrating cultural diversity and fostering intercultural competence are central to effective EIL-oriented curriculum design (Matsuda, 2012; Kirkpatrick, 2010). Adapting teaching methods and materials to meet the needs of international learners.

Assessment

Assessing English proficiency in international contexts requires moving beyond native-speaker norms (Seidlhofer, 2011; Selvi & Galloway, 2023). The book addresses challenges and solutions in assessing English proficiency in a way that acknowledges the diverse contexts in which English is used.

Teacher Education

This section provides insights into preparing teachers to effectively teach EIL, emphasizing the need for ongoing professional development and critical reflection.  Teacher education programs must emphasize critical reflection and ongoing professional development to address the realities of global English use (Selvi & Galloway, 2023; Matsuda, 2012). Equipping teachers with the necessary knowledge and skills to teach English globally.

Case Studies

Real-world examples and case studies illustrate how the principles of EIL can be implemented in various educational contexts around the globe.

Critical Analysis

I found this book is a valuable resource for us as a teacher educators, researchers, and policymakers. The writer successfully argued for a paradigm shift in how English is taught and moving away from traditional native-speaker. Teaching English as an International Language challenges traditional native-speaker ideologies by recognizing plural forms and functions of English (Jenkins, 2007; Matsuda, 2012).  This book has great advantages such as Comprehensive Coverage: It covers a wide range of topics relevant to EIL, providing a holistic view of the field. Practical Application: the comprehension of practical strategies and case studies makes the theoretical concepts capable and applicable for practitioners. Interdisciplinary Approach: Drawing on insights from linguistics, education, and sociocultural studies enriches the discussion.

Crucial and Developed Area of the Book

The most crucial and developed area of the book are given below.

Technological Integration

More discussion on how technology can support EIL teaching and learning would be beneficial, given the increasing role of digital tools in education.

Local Contexts

While the book provides a global perspective, more detailed exploration of specific local contexts could enhance its relevance for diverse readers.

Conclusion

Teaching English as an International Language is a timely and essential read for anyone involved in English language education. Both writers Ali Fuad Selvi and Nicola Galloway provided a thought-provoking and practical guide to navigating the complexities of teaching English in a globalized world. Their emphasis on inclusivity and respect for linguistic diversity is particularly noteworthy, making this book a significant contribution to the field. Teaching English as an International Language promotes linguistic diversity, cultural inclusivity, and more effective global communication in a globalized world (Kachru, 1992; Selvi & Galloway, 2023).Teaching English as an International Language represents a significant shift in language education, reflecting the realities of a globalized world. While there are challenges to its implementation, the potential benefits of TEIL in promoting linguistic diversity, cultural inclusivity, and effective global communication.

Author’s Bio: Mr. Nar Bahadur Bist is an ELT practitioner from Doti, Nepal. He is currently pursuing an MPhil in ELT from Kathmandu University, School of Education. He is an English instructor at Seti Technical School, Rajpur, and a secondary-level teacher at Martyrs Memorial Residential Secondary School, Doti. His areas of interest include English language teaching, linguistic study, EMI and ELT study of language, and teacher professional development. He can be reached at narbist22@gmail.com.

References

Selvi, A. F., & Galloway, N. (2023). Teaching English as an international language. Oxford University Press. ISBNs: 9781009462495 (hb), 9781108821230 (pb), 9781108902755 (oc). ISSNs: 2632‑4415 (online), 2632‑4407 (print)

Jenkins, J. (2007). English as a lingua franca: Attitude and identity. Oxford University Press.

Kachru, B. B. (1992). The other tongue: English across cultures (2nd ed.). University of Illinois Press.

Kirkpatrick, A. (2010). World Englishes: Implications for international communication and English language teaching. Cambridge University Press.

Matsuda, A. (Ed.). (2012). Principles and practices of teaching English as an international language. Multilingual Matters.

Seidlhofer, B. (2011). Understanding English as a lingua franca. Oxford University Press.

Canagarajah, S. (2006). Ethnographic methods in language policy research. In T. Ricento (Ed.), An introduction to language policy: Theory and method (pp. 115–130). Blackwell.

Welcome to Second Quarterly Issue of ELT Choutari-2025, 17(114)

Dear Valued Readers and Contributors,

Greetings!

We are pleased to announce the release of the Issue of ELT Choutari (October-December 2025). This issue presents a collection of reflective accounts from English language teachers and practitioners, offering diverse perspectives on teaching, learning, and research.

Since it is a generic issue, it includes articles from diverse fields of English language teaching in the context of Nepal. ELT Choutari is a platform to share the English language teachers’ experiences regarding their practices and experiences. This issue is the result of the same. For this, we are grateful to all the contributors. We encourage English language teachers and practitioners to contribute in the future issues as this can share and document our reflective practices.

The following section includes the contributors with the gist of their reflections. We hope their experiences and anecdotes will benefit our esteemed readers.

Mr. Dev Ram Joshi, in his article, explores the engagement of learners in English language learning through project-based learning integrated as internal assessment in the secondary level curriculum. His technical action research reflects that his students increased the time to study English subject, developed their writing skill including handwriting and composition skills and presentation skills such as pronunciation, clarity, and confidence. Meanwhile, they started to learn English by studying other reference materials as well.

Likewise, Mr. Dammar Singh Saud in his article drawing on personal experience and educational theories, argues for reflective, context-sensitive, collaborative, and well-resourced Teacher Professional Development. He advocated that, learning from countries like Finland and Singapore, Nepal must prioritise teacher agency, mentorship, digital readiness, and long-term systemic reform.

Similarly, Mr. Khem Raj Rauteda, in his article, reflects his experience implementing translanguaging pedagogy to enhance learner engagement in a multilingual secondary classroom in Nepal. Through reflecting on his role as a facilitator and co-learner, he found that translanguaging nurtured culturally responsive pedagogy, strengthened relationships, and empowered students, providing valuable insights for inclusive English language teaching in multilingual contexts.

Similarly, Mr. Janak Sigdel, in his article, explores the ongoing challenges of implementing Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in rural community schools in Nepal. His reflection highlights key barriers, including inadequate infrastructure, lack of electricity, limited internet access, and low digital literacy among teachers. His article underscores the growing digital divide between urban and rural schools, advocating for policy interventions and capacity-building programmes to promote more equitable and sustainable ICT integration in education.

Likewise, Mr. Nar Bahadur Bist, in his article, deals with the complicated and changing nature of English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) in language planning and policy in Nepal. He discusses how English has established a dominant presence in the education system, as well as a larger presence in society, despite Nepal’s non-colonial relationship with Britain, shaping ideologies, creating inequalities, and affecting cultural identity.

Moreover, Mr. Arjun Jung Rayamajhi, in his article, discusses the integration of ChatGPT in English language teaching in Nepalese community schools with its opportunities and challenges. He argues that ChatGPT offers the possibility to experience a personalized learning process and support engagement growth in the underprivileged setting. However, it also emphasizes the significance of the human factor, critical thinking, and ethical competence.

For your convenience, here are the hyperlinks to the blog posts:

  1. Fostering Learner Investment in Nepalese EFL Classrooms through Project-Based Language Learning Approach by Dev Ram Joshi
  2. English Language Teacher Professional Development in Nepal: A Reflective Perspective by Dammar Singh Saud
  3. Enhancing Learner Engagement through Translanguaging Pedagogy: A Reflective Narrative from a Multilingual ELT Classroom in Nepal by Khem Raj Rauteda
  4. Implementing ICT in Rural Community Schools: A Reflective Journey from a Student to a Teacher by Janak Sigdel
  5. English Medium Craze in Community Schools: Issues of Linguistic Imperialism and Social Injustice by Nar Bahadur Bist
  6. Integrating ChatGPT in English Language Teaching in Nepalese Community Schools: Opportunities and Challenges by Arjun Jung Rayamajhi

Lastly, we extend heartfelt gratitude to all our editors and reviewers — Ganesh Kumar Bastola, Jeevan Karki, Dr. Nani Babu Ghimire, Dr. Jnanu Raj Poudel, Sagar Poudel, Binod Duwadi, Puskar Chaudhary, Dr. Yadu Prasad Gnawali, and Dasharath Rai—for their dedicated efforts in bringing this issue to completion.

ELT Choutari is a platform for researchers, scholars, educators, and practitioners to share insights, practices, and narratives from classrooms and communities. We invite you to contribute to our upcoming issue by submitting your articles and reflections to 2elt.choutari@gmail.com.

Happy Reading!

Lead Editor: Mohan Singh Saud

Co-Editor: Ganesh Kumar Bastola

 

Welcome to Third Quarterly Issue 17 (112)

Dear Esteemed Readers and Contributors,

Greetings!

We are delighted to announce the release of the Third quarterly edition of ELT Choutari (October-December 2024), dedicated as a special issue focusing on “Mother Tongue Based Multilingual Education Policies Practices and Research Nepal.”

Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) in Nepal is grounded in the belief that students learn best in their native language, which enhances cognitive development and academic success. Introduced after Nepal’s democratic transition in 1990, MTB-MLE aims to preserve linguistic diversity while improving educational outcomes for children from various ethnic and language backgrounds. Despite strong policy frameworks supporting MTB-MLE, its implementation has faced challenges, including limited resources, teacher training, and community resistance. The policy’s success hinges on developing contextually appropriate teaching models and addressing the complex multilingual needs of Nepal’s classrooms, particularly in rural and marginalized areas.

This edition presents an exclusive interview with two renowned scholars—Professor Dr. Yogendra Prasad Yadava and Professor Dr. Ram Ashish Giri—as they explore the complexities of MTB-MLE (Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education) policies, practices, and research in Nepal. Delving into its multifaceted challenges and opportunities, their discussion illuminates the cultural, educational, and sociopolitical dynamics shaping language-in-education reforms in the region.

Professor Yadava highlights Nepal’s policy-practice disconnect in implementing Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB MLE). Despite constitutional guarantees for mother-tongue education, contradictory laws impede implementation. He identifies systemic challenges: underdeveloped policies, scarce resources, and lack of localized materials. Effective execution requires teacher training, community language awareness, and rigorous research to evaluate and refine programs. Yadava stresses collaborative partnerships with academic and civil institutions to align practical strategies with evidence-based research, ensuring policy coherence.

Professor Ram Ashish Giri discusses the cognitive, pedagogical, and linguistic challenges of Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) in Nepal. He emphasizes the importance of designing policies that reflect the country’s multilingual reality and align with local aspirations, advocating for the inclusion of English alongside native languages. Giri critiques the gaps between policy intentions and practical implementation, citing inadequate resources, teacher training, and community support.

Additionally, the issue includes three scholarly papers by devoted researchers from Australia and Nepal :

Naomi Fillmore’s paper explores the challenges and successes of incorporating Indigenous and minority languages into education systems globally. She examines initiatives in Nepal, Australia, the Philippines, and New Zealand, highlighting the importance of mother tongue-based multilingual education (MTB-MLE). While these countries face similar issues like resource development and teacher training, each context offers unique approaches. Fillmore emphasizes the crucial role of community involvement, policy support, and culturally appropriate educational content.

Dr. Uma Nath Sharma discusses the integration of students’ mother tongues (MT) in English as a Foreign Language (EFL) education in Nepal, highlighting both the theoretical benefits and practical challenges. He emphasizes how MT enhances comprehension, cognitive development, and cultural identity, supported by theories like Cummins’ interdependence hypothesis. Despite these advantages, societal biases, teacher reluctance, and institutional pressures favoring English create obstacles. Sharma advocates for the use of translanguaging as a transformative pedagogical approach, allowing students to use their MT alongside English.

Dr. Bishnu Khadka presents the tension between Mother-Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) policies and English Medium Education (EME) practices in Nepal, focusing on equity and inclusion. Analyzing policy documents, reports, and field studies, Khadka identifies challenges such as inadequate resources, insufficient teacher training, and sociocultural biases favoring dominant languages. The study highlights the gap between policy intentions and grassroots realities, which limits marginalized communities’ access to quality education.

For your convenience, here are the hyperlinks to the articles:

  1. Mother Tongue Based Multilingual Education Policies, Practices and Research in Nepal by Professor Dr. Yogendra Prasad Yadava
  2. Mother Tongue Based Multilingual Education Policies, Practices and Research in Nepal by Professor Dr. Ram Ashish Giri
  3. Global Perspectives on Indigenous Languages in Education: Commonalities, Challenges, and Reflections by Naomi Fillmore
  4. Reflections on the Use of Students’ Mother Tongue in Nepalese EFL Classes by Uma Nath Sharma
  5. Mother-Tongue or Other-Tongue Education? by Dr. Bishnu Kumar Khadka

We would like to express our sincere gratitude to our co-editor, Dr. Nani Babu Ghimire, along with all our editors and reviewers—Jeevan Karki, Ganesh Kumar Bastola, Mohan Singh Saud, Sagar Poudel, Binod Duwadi, Puskar Chaudhary, Yadu Gnawali, and Dasharath Rai—for their unwavering dedication and invaluable contributions in bringing this issue to the readers.

ELT Choutari is a platform for researchers, scholars, educators, and practitioners to share insights, practices, and narratives from classrooms and communities. We invite you to contribute to our upcoming anniversary issue (January-March 2025) by submitting your articles and blogs to 2elt.choutari@gmail.com.

If you find value in the interviews, articles, and reflective pieces, please share them within your circles and feel free to leave your comments below each piece.

Happy Reading!

Thank you.

Dr. Jnanu Raj Paudel- Lead Editor of this issue

Dr. Nani Babu Ghimire- Co- Editor of this issue

Is English in Education a Medium of Instruction or Destruction?

Mohan Singh Saud

Introduction

Schools can today participate in committing linguistic genocide through their choice of the medium of formal education – and they do. (Skutnabb-Kangas, 2010, p. 212)

The above quotation by Skutnabb-Kangas (2010) ought to be self-evident. The situation in some public schools in Nepal is that they are running after English medium instruction. In Nepal, the official language is Nepali and English is taken as a foreign language. It shows that the language of instruction in schools should be Nepali as it is the formal language in Nepal. Yet English as a medium of instruction policy has been adopted by some schools especially in urban areas believing that English medium brings so-called quality. Are they bringing quality in education or committing linguistic genocide as Skutnabb-Kangas says?

The medium of instruction (MOI) policy has been a controversial issue in the context of Nepal. Nepal has adopted a neoliberal policy regarding the MOI. CDC (2019) states that the MOI at the Basic Level (Grades 1-8) will be either mother tongue or Nepali. NCF states that social studies and Nepali should not be taught in English; however, other subjects can be taught in English at the Basic Level (p. 36) at the secondary level (Grades 9-12), the MOI will be Nepali or English.  The government policy mentions that children can get education in their mother tongue since it is their right; or Nepali can be the MOI as it is the lingua franca of Nepal. Neglecting the linguistic human rights (Skutnabb-Kangas, 2006) of the children to get education in their language, there has been a shift to English Medium Instruction (EMI) in some public schools in Nepal. Is it justifiable to do so or are the public schools violating the language rights of the school children? This is a debatable question to be discussed in public discourses. Considering this issue, this paper discusses whether EMI is for quality education or the destruction of minority languages in Nepal.

Discussion

It is agreed that students learn better when they understand what the teacher is saying (Brock-Utne, 2010; Klaus, 2001), and this is possible only through the learners’ mother tongues. If the children are provided education in other languages, they often remain silent or become puzzled. Let me relate this issue to the experience of one of my colleagues. When my colleague (Tamang as the mother tongue) was admitted to school, he didn’t understand anything that the teachers said or taught. There was another Tamang student who also knew the Nepali language. Then he used to ask what the teachers said. This example clarifies that students learn better in their language only. What we infer from this event is that we are destroying the knowledge of the students. Learning is for the knowledge of the subject matter. It does not mean that we can get better knowledge in English only. If this was true, Chinese, Korean and Japanese learners would be the weakest ones in the world, but it is not so. These countries are far forward in science and technology including education. Therefore, adopting EMI and compelling the learners to get education is destroying their clear-cut knowledge in content areas.

Another argument is that indigenous languages are destroyed through the adoption of EMI policy in schools. Languages get protected, survived, and promoted through their use, especially in education. Skutnabb-Kangas (2010) argues that schools can kill languages that had survived for centuries when their speakers were not exposed to formal education. This is what happened through the adoption of the EMI policy in the public schools of Nepal. Nepal is a multilingual, multicultural and multiracial country with 131 indigenous languages spoken by 125 ethnic groups (Language Commission, 2020). Since there has been a growing trend of using EMI in public schools in Nepal, learners’ mother tongues are endangered. Once when I was in the field collecting data for my research work, one Rana student (Rana language is one of the indigenous languages of Nepal) who was studying in a public school in Kailali district where EMI was implemented said, “I don’t want to learn and speak my mother tongue. If there is no use of my language in school and in the market, then why should I use it? Only my parents speak it but I use Nepali to talk to them at home.” This shows that the use of EMI is one of the causes that obstruct students to use local or other indigenous languages at home. In my neighborhood, one family belonging to the Newar community. Both the father and the mother are educated and job holders. Their children study in a private English medium school. I have never heard them speaking the Newari language even with their children. When I asked, “Why don’t you use the Newari language at home with your children?” The father replied, “Sir, what’s the use of using our language if it has no value in society? So we want our children to learn only Nepali and English.” Thus, there is linguistic genocide (Skutnabb-Kangas, 2000) or the policy that encourages language shifts in multilingual societies. EMI in education is playing a crucial role in this case. Skutnabb-Kangas (2001) argues that linguistic human rights are necessary for maintaining linguistic and cultural diversity on earth. Only the use of mother tongues in education can support the maintenance of linguistic diversity, thereby preserving and promoting indigenous languages.

English is taken as a killer language (Gutiérrez Estrada, & Schecter, 2018; Khaled, 2020; Schrijver, 2013). If so, how can EMI policy in education remain its exception? Although English is a global lingua franca, it is an agent of making other languages disappear because of people’s attraction towards the use of English in education, media, public spheres, tourism, and other sectors.

I argue after Brock-Utne (2010) that English in education is the language of destruction rather than instruction in two senses. First, the use of EMI in education is destroying and limiting the knowledge of education in the learners since they do not get a clear-cut concept of the subject matter in English. Second, the use of EMI in education is destroying the learners’ mother tongues.

Conclusion

I conclude my argument that the only way to preserve and protect the indigenous languages thereby imparting crystal clear knowledge to the learners about the subject matters is through the use of mother tongue-based education especially up to basic level (1-8) education. It is believed that the more languages the learners know; the more cognitive development they have. Following this assumption, I propose that some subjects related to local knowledge can be taught in the learners’ mother tongues, the subjects of national importance can be in Nepali, and the subjects like Maths, Science, and Computers can be taught in English. It is the responsibility of the nation to protect the indigenous languages of the country. The linguistic and cultural diversity of a country is the property and identity. Therefore, the linguistic human rights of children must be preserved. We can never imagine this through the use of EMI in education.

References

Brock-Utne, B. (2010). English as the language of instruction or destruction–how do teachers and students in Tanzania cope? In Language of instruction in Tanzania and South Africa-Highlights from a project (pp. 77-98). Brill.

Gutiérrez Estrada, M. R., & Schecter, S. R. (2018). English as a” Killer Language”? Multilingual Education in an Indigenous Primary Classroom in Northwestern Mexico. Journal of Educational Issues, 4(1), 122-147.

Khaled, D. Y. A. (2020). English as a killer language: South Africa as a Case Study. International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Translation, 3(3), 72-79.

Klaus, D. (2001). The use of indigenous languages in Early Basic Education in Papua New Guinea: A model for elsewhere? Paper presented the Annual Conference of the Comparative and International Education Society held in Washington DC. March 17, 2001.

Language Commission (2020). Annual Report (5th). Language Commission.

CDC, (2019). National level curriculum framework for school education in Nepal. Sanothimi: Curriculum Development Center, Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, Government of Nepal.

Schrijver, P. (2013). Languages Competing for Speakers: English as a Killer Language. In Language Contact and the Origins of the Germanic Languages (pp. 20-22). Routledge.

Skutnabb-Kangas, T. (2000). Linguistic genocide in education – or worldwide diversity and human rights? Routledge.

Skutnabb-Kangas, T. (2001). The globalisation of (educational) language rights. International Review of Education, 47(3), 201-219.

Skutnabb-Kangas, T. (2006). Language policy and linguistic human rights. An introduction to language policy: Theory and method, 273-291.

Skutnabb-Kangas, T. (2010). Language rights. Handbook of pragmatic highlights. Society and Language Use, 7, 212-232.

About Author

Mohan Singh Saud is an Associate Professor of English Language Education, ELT trainer, book writer, poet, editor, and researcher from Nepal. He is the visiting faculty at Chandigarh University, Panjab, India. His areas of interests in research include grammar teaching, teachers’ professional development, medium of instruction, English medium instruction (EMI), mother tongue-based medium of instruction, teaching English as an international language, English language teachers’ training and education, linguistic diversity, and globalisation.

[To cite this: Saud. M.S., (2022, October 15). Is English in Education a Medium of Instruction or Destruction? [blog post]. Retrieved from https://eltchoutari.com/2022/10/is-english-in-education-a-medium-of-instruction-or-destruction/] 

English medium instruction in school education: parents’ perspectives

Dipak Prasad Mishra
Surendra Bhatt
Abstract

English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) has become widespread due to globalization and the growing demand of developing nations, particularly in Nepalese public schools which are assumed as a symbol of quality education.  This new trend of adopting EMI caught the attention of parents on the impact and changes in education. The study explores the perceptions of parents on the implementation of EMI in public schools through Bourdieu’s lens of the symbolic power of language theory. Based on an in-depth interview with three parents of Kanchanpur, the perceptions on the implementation of EMI in school education are explored. The data analysis reveals EMI is perceived as an investment for developing advanced English skills and an uplifting lifestyle. The result shows EMI is just a fashion and propaganda to increase the number of students. Despite the demand of parents in society, some public schools are switching to EMI without proper preparation. Also, EMI is the preference as a mantra of competition. Findings indicate that the public schools need to close their ears for howling mob i.e. EMI as synonyms of quality education without proper preparation and readiness because hunting needs loaded guns and hunting skills.

Keywords:  EMI, fashion, social strata, competition

Introduction

As English is an international language, its use in different areas of social science is growing rapidly all over the world. The use of English from business to education is rapidly increasing. The rapid use of English in different aspects of society is dominating other languages of the world. Further, the English language is becoming a global lingua franca that links critical turns such as globalization, global economy, transnational communication, education, and the Internet (Sah& Li, 2018). Since English is integrated into every aspect of life, it has become obligatory in order to uplift social, economic status in the globe. In this regard, Bourdieu (1993) states English has become one of the best sources of achieving power, linguistic capital, and access. We visualize the choice of English in different schools even in remote areas of the world. With this notion, non-native countries are adopting English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) though its implementation is great intimidation to the indigenous languages (House, 2014). Its effect is visible in the education sector where these countries are adopting EMI even from the basic level. As a result, English is practiced as an academic subject from the very beginning of formal education (Dearden, 2015), as people assume that EMI provides better socioeconomic mobility (Sah & Li, 2018). So, the hegemony of English is vividly felt in every aspect of social life including school education.

However, EMI is one of the prominent issues in the context of Nepal where private schools have already adopted and public schools have been mushrooming. EMI is taken as the prestige of school though schools are under-resourced (Gnawali, 2018) and lacking will power in real classrooms. Implementing EMI in such a situation has created problems in students learning achievement and creativity. In this regard, Sah and Li (2018) say implementing EMI without proper preparation resulted in negative outcomes: students neither achieve content knowledge nor English language skills. On the contrary, Evans, and Morrison (2016) state the graduates of EMI schools seem more confident in English ability, received superior examination grades, and able to adjust to diverse social contexts. As the entire world has been emphasizing the English language, countries like Nepal, India, Indonesia, and Ghana have been switching towards EMI without proper preparation.

In developing and non-English speaking countries  EMI has different faces. As an instance, EMI in Indonesia is taken as a symbol of prestige and power where English Language teachers play an agentive role (Zacharias, 2013) for its promotion. In the same way in Taiwan, students agreed that English instruction helped them improve their English proficiency (Chang, 2010) though, in Pakistan, it was neglected to point its negative effects in mainstream education (Ahmed, 2011). According to Haider and Fang (2019), English is proving linguistic capital for elites although the lack of opportunities in general school leads to failure in professional life in Pakistan. On the other hand in China, Hu, Li,& Lei (2014) portrait EMI as a gatekeeper of access to English and other potential benefits. As English and its use in education have been increasing, many public schools are adopting it massively as a medium of instruction. To put it in a nutshell, in some countries EMI is a boon and for a few others, it’s a bane.

Similarly, parents send their children to private schools in urban areas because of their global status. They are willing to get and give education through EMI, even though they have low economic status. English is synonymously taken as a part of skills development (Erling, 2014) so all parents prefer to send their children to EMI implemented schools. Similarly, English is taken as a superior language and English-educated people are taken as highly prestigious in the society, therefore, parents are demanding EMI even in public schools though policies encourage mother tongue-based multilingual education (Phyak, 2016). This shows the gap between policy and practice. Similarly, implementing EMI created tension among parents having low economic status though they strongly prefer it. In this vain, Poudel (2019), says in the context of Nepal, English is the most influential language among upper and middle classes. It has created the strata in society as EMI educated are taken as superior and Non-EMI educated are as inferior.

However, most of the research on the EMI is primarily focused on teachers’ readiness, policy analysis, the effect of EMI, and students’ demands. The real perceptions of parents from the root level have not been well explored among scholars and policymakers in the context of Nepal. This study, therefore, aimed to explore the perception of parents’ on the implementation of EMI in public schools. It further tried to answer the question ‘how do parents narrate their experiences of sending their children to EMI implemented public school?’

Despite these useful studies, there is still a dearth of research investigating the perceptions of parents on the implementation of EMI in public schools. This study, therefore, aims to explore the perceptions of parents on the implementation of EMI in public schools.  This study addresses the following question:

How do parents narrate their experiences of sending their children to EMI implemented public school?’

Reviewing Nepalese language planning and policy status

Language planning is an important process that enhances and reforms the entire linguistic situation of the country. It is also the national or international strategy to promote the selected language(s). Many ups and downs are found in the language planning of our country. Regarding this, Bist (2015) writes that the Nepal National Education Planning Commission (NNEPC) 1953 AD suggested that English needs to be started from grade four to Bachelor level as a compulsory subject. However, through its report in 1956, the commission recommended removing English from the Medium of instruction, which was in practice since the Rana regime.

Furthermore, the Education Act (1971) was amended by The Education and Sports Related Some Nepal Acts Amendment Act (2007) with the policy that the Nepali language or English language or both languages shall be the medium of instruction in a school in its section seven, subsection one. Similarly, in subsection two (a) it is included that the mother tongue may be the medium of instruction up to primary education, and in subsection two (d) we can find the policy of English language medium while teaching a compulsory subject of English. Therefore, this document of the Education Act permits public schools to use English as a medium of instruction while teaching any academic subjects in the schools (Education Act, 1971).

Multilingual Education Directive (2010) declares mother tongue to be the medium of instruction at the pre-primary level and basic level in class (1- 3) to teach all subjects except Nepali and English subjects, and mother tongue or the language of government officials to be medium of instruction at basic (classes 4- 5) level. The Constitution of Nepal (2015) includes the right of every Nepali community living in Nepal to get education in its mother tongue up to the secondary level, in Article No. 31, sub-article No.5 (Constitution of Nepal, 2015). Regarding other language planning documents, Phyak (2016) says if we closely look at the Ministry of Education’s policies and plans such as Education for All, Millennium Development Goals, School Sector Reform Plan, and National Curriculum Framework, it wants to promote multilingual education by considering children’s home/community languages a resource for an equitable and quality education.

Symbolic power of language

The symbolic power of language believes education is one of the most effective means of immortalization of the existing social pattern (Benbenishty et al., 2005). It further gives proper justification for the social inequalities and recognition of the cultural heritage. More specifically, Bourdieu (1977) highlighted the symbolic power of language which is the symbol of imposition. Symbolic power here is a power of constituting given through utterances, of making people see and believe, of confirming or transforming the vision of the world (Loader, 1997). Further, the language given legitimate status involves the claim to be heard, believed, and obeyed and that can exercise its effectiveness and effectiveness of the mechanism (Bourdieu, 1991).

In the context of Nepal, EMI is practiced as a means to gain power in society. In our own experience, a person having good command over English gains high prestige and reputation. As Bourdieu (1977) said that the powerful language imposes different ideologies, the practice is seen in the Nepalese schools by implementing EMI. Existing scenario presents EMI as the symbol of power which controls the social aspects from education to economy. Likewise, EMI has brought strata among the schools in the nation. Schools having EMI tend to be superior than the non-EMI schools. This division is clearly seen in our context. So, analyzing this power play of EMI, Symbolic Power of Language theory was found appropriate in our study.

The review helped us to get an overview of EMI policies in Nepal and it has also revealed the importance of multilingual education in the context of Nepal. As the study aimed to explore the implementation of the English language as a medium of instruction, this review created a base for analyzing the real context which later helped us to frame out our findings. Further, analyzing the present status of local languages and imposition of English from the previous studies created the proper gap and demand to explore more.

Method

As the study aimed to explore subjective realities from the real field, it is qualitative in nature. The site of the study was Kanchanpur (one of the districts of Western Nepal) and three parents whose children study in EMI implemented public school were our participants. To explore their perception of EMI, we chose them purposely. To maintain balance on the existing contemporary strata of the society, we selected one participant from the lower class (Ramesh) level and other two from the middle-class level (Sampurna and Ram).

Ramesh was from a lower-class family, aged in his mid-thirties. He enrolled his children in a public school implementing EMI. He was an auto driver having five members in the family. He had two daughters and a son studying in the same school. Similarly, our second participant Ram was a middle-class man, aged in his mid-fifties. He had stayed in Malaysia for three years and had one daughter who studied in class nine. Earlier, he had enrolled his daughter in a public school where the Nepali medium of instruction was implemented. He did not pay any monthly fees there. After coming back from Malaysia, he preferred to enroll his daughter in a public school where EMI was practiced even by paying. And the third one was Sampurna, a middle-class man with four members in the family having two daughters. He was a farmer and his wife was a housewife. He enrolled both his daughters in public schools where EMI was practiced.

We collected data through in-depth interviews. Moreover, we interviewed them thrice and it was audio-recorded. The first interview created the opportunity for the follow-up interviews which ensured the contextual experiences. We conducted a second round of interviews only after the data from the first phase were categorized into different themes, and the analysis was underway. The frequent informal conversations made our data more lively and interesting. The interpretive paradigm was employed to explore parents’ perceptions of EMI. After that, we coded data using thematic chunks such as English as a fashion, EMI as a symbol of power, and English as a mantra of competition. We developed all those codes after a careful understanding of the collected data. The codes were further put into analytical memos, which depicted emerging themes. These themes were developed on the basis of the research question and objective. As every participant is value-led, we valued the participants’ views and had prolonged engagement during formal interviews and informal tea talks.  For ethical issues, we took the consent of the participants and used pseudo names for privacy so that it won’t harm their personal and professional life.

Results and discussion

As this research aimed to explore the perception of parents on implementing EMI in public school, they take it as symbolic power, fashion, and weapon to compete. On the basis of perceptions of the parents their themes were made and discussed in this section.

Power Play of EMI

From the parents’ perspective in Nepal, English is taken as a symbol of power since English education is taken as highly prestigious in society. The success story of private schools has led to many Nepalese parents who preferred an English medium education for their children regardless of their socioeconomic status. In this regard our second participant  Ram (pseudonym) shared:

When I was in Malaysia, I came to know the value of English in today’s world. I was thinking of sending my daughter to an elite institutional school but I realized that I could not handle it from an economic perspective. Later, I enrolled her in a public school where EMI is practiced.  I am happy right now because my daughter is learning English. I know those people speak English, they get respect in society and they will get jobs very soon.

It is believed that English-educated people are more intelligent and wise in the community though English is not widely accepted in everyday communication. According to Bourdieu (1993) language regulates the power and prestige in society which is seen as practice. In the same line our third participants Sampurna added:

I could not study at the campus level, I had a dream to send my daughters to college for higher education. My friends share that English is very important, the upcoming generation won’t get any job without English. Then only I realized the value of English in each and every sector. Sometimes I spent time with my friends in the teashop, everyone used to talk about their daughters and sons. They feel proud of themselves for sending kids to more expensive schools where English is primarily focused. I also felt that without English, no one would get a job and opportunity in this century. So, I have sent my daughters to public schools where English is prioritized.

Analyzing both of the views above, the English language has a great impact and position in the world so he preferred to send his daughter to EMI School not only for content knowledge but also for the English language. Participants believed EMI is very important in school education, it has increased the number of students in public schools and they know the value of the English language. They believed that English promotes prestige in the community and EMI helps students to facilitate the learning of content and English skills (Sah, 2020). It has become such a well-adopted medium of instruction in higher education in Nepal. Despite having low economic status, people show keen interest to enroll their children in English medium school because they know that English is a powerful language. Likewise, looking at it from the symbolic power perspective, lower class, marginalized and disadvantaged groups of people try to uplift their status with the use of powerful language (Bourdieu, 1993) i.e. English in the Society.

This shows EMI in today’s demand in developing countries like Nepal. So, English is for economic development, social mobility, and participation in the global economy (Bruthiaux, 2002) as English has achieved global status. English is taken as a weapon in order to bring happiness to family and community and uplift the socio-economic status of the people.

Fashion in the market

EMI is growing as a kind of fashion. This fashion is linked to “cultural capital” in a globalized society where parents of public schools want to switch schools (Lareau & Horvat, 1999). As new fashion first attracts the attention of the people who are not in the habit of being changed i.e. lower-class people, the same group of people are more attracted to enroll their children in EMI schools. In this regard, Bourdieu (1997) states cultural capital consists of familiarity with the dominant culture in society and especially the ability to understand and use “educated” language, and here in the community English is accepted as an educated language.  In this line Ramesh provoked:

I have never ever studied English in my life. Nowadays, we are bound to learn English. My daughter always forced me to send her to an English medium school. The prime reason was that her best friends study in English medium school. In my locality, no one studies in public schools where the Nepali medium is practiced. Those incidents compelled me to enroll her in an English medium school. And we are happy for EMI in public school. 

In the same line, Ram the first participant put forwarded his view as:

I see everyone sending children to the boarding school with well-ironed dresses and ties. This really touches the heart and made me feel like sending children to boarding school. This is a new culture now. Everyone sends children to boarding school even if they don’t have food to eat. Except for English, there is not much change in education but also everybody’s wish.

Participants believed that English provides a better academic and professional career in national and international arenas. Similarly, people believe they are inferior if they don’t study or educate their children in English Medium.

This is because, to some extent, receiving English instruction at a younger age gives sound input and proficiency (Bahrani & Sim, 2012). Participants and children believed that switching to EMI responded to the demand of the present day and would not be dominated by other colleagues in the community. This demand and wish of English from the point of view of symbolic power theory, has been developing and promoting the status of lower and middle-class people. The representational practice of English in education helps in achieving power in society (Hall, 1997). It is how an exhibition constructs and persuades meaning through demonstrating a path through meaning. It is believed that everyone is running behind English because of its popularity.

Mantra of competition

Many public schools have been opting towards EMI to compete with the institutional schools as well as other public EMI schools. The reason behind this is that the number of students is also decreasing day by day. Participants opined that EMI is just for competition rather than collaboration and quality education. In this regard, Ram said:

I have earned a BA in English. After that, I could not get a chance to resume my study because of family problems. Nowadays, I have been engaging in small businesses. Currently, I see that many public schools are switching to EMI. I confidently say that it is a big issue in today’s school education system. In public school, some teachers cannot even read accurately, how can they teach students effectively?  There is not any sort of training and enough teaching materials. I believe that this is just for increasing the number of students by showing advertisements for EMI.

In the perceptions of common people, public schools are switching to EMI only just for the sake of advertisement so that they could increase the number of students although the teachers’ readiness, training, and proficiency are in debate. They have a motto to compete with children in the international market with the English language. In the same way, Sampurna viewed, “ Students having good English can tackle problems in the modern age.”  He further added, “We were not educated with English so we are facing so many challenges in the digital era. So I send my children to EMI school”. So, the symbolic power (Bourdieu, 1997) of EMI as a linguistic capital is to compete with institutional schools in national and international markets.

It is evident that some public schools are switching to EMI without enough preparation and infrastructure (Sah & Li, 2018). With the motto of competition, many public schools have been implementing EMI but the part of proper preparation and readiness is not properly studied.  This resulted in fragmentation in the result. In this regard, Sah and Li (2018) further believed students developed neither content knowledge nor English language skills. This vividly presents the lack of proper preparation and ineffectiveness of EMI in public schools even spending a huge amount of economic and other efforts. Similarly, EMI  created the strata among the students in terms of the economy and social status. In the name of English, there has been a stratum of educational division and injustice for the children who are from a lower socioeconomic status and are not able to get access to EMI (Kuchah, 2018). This brings conflict among different ethnic groups in the community. In this line, Sampurna added, “English is a fake myth it does provide quality education but only attract the attention”. Students willing to have education in EMI are compelled to face psychological effects due to poor economic background as education in EMI is expensive, though EMI was taken as a strategy to sell the tag of EMI education in the linguistic market (Bourdieu, 1977). In a nutshell, EMI is just a showcase to increase the students in school rather than providing quality education.

Conclusion

The study employing Bourdieu’s (1977) symbolic power of language theory looked at the perceptions of parents on the implementation of EMI in school education. As the data revealed parents idealised EMI as a symbol of power and linguistic capital to develop English skills through its real flavour is not achieved because of the lack of preparation and readiness. Switching to EMI without enough preparation and supervision, under-resourced conditions, and improper lead resulted in students’ low proficiency in both English and non-English subjects. On the other hand, it was found EMI in public schools is just propaganda to collect more students which creates a problem for lower and middle-class people as it is more expensive. As this study was limited to the perceptions of parents in a district, future research can be in unpacking the critical analysis of EMI practices and their effect on classroom and students’ achievements in different parts of the country.

About the authors

Mr. Dipak Prasad Mishra is a research Scholar at Kathmandu University, School of Education. Mr. Mishra is Head of the Department of English at Valley View English School. He is a Life Member of the Nepal English Language Teachers’ Association (NELTA). Mr. Mishra is interested in learners’ autonomy and critical thinking.

Mr. Surendra Bhatt is an MPhil Scholar at Kathmandu University, School of Education. Currently, he is the head of the English Department at Charles Darwin Academy (Management College). Life Member of the Nepal English Language Teachers’ Association (NELTA), Mr. Bhatt is an executive member of the Geo-linguistics Society of Nepal. Deputy Academic Director of ISTER Nepal, Mr. Bhatta keeps interests in teacher well-being and teacher professional development.

References

Ahmed, S. I. (2011). Issue of the medium of instruction in Pakistan. International journal of social sciences and education, 1(1), 66-82.

Bahrani, T., & Sim, T. S. (2012). Audiovisual News, Cartoons, and Films as Sources of Authentic Language Input and Language Proficiency Enhancement. Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology-TOJET, 11(4), 56-64.

Benbenishty, R., Astor, R. A., & Astor, R. (2005). School violence in context: Culture, neighborhood, family, school, and gender. Oxford University Press.

Bist, S. D. (2015). Shifting the medium of instruction in Nepalese schools: An attitudinal study of ELT practitioners [Unpublished Masters’ Thesis, Tribhuvan University, Nepal]

Bourdieu, P. (1977). The economics of linguistic exchanges. Information (International Social Science Council), 16(6), 645-668.

Bourdieu, P. (1991). Language and symbolic power. Harvard University Press.

Bourdieu, P. (1993). The field of cultural production: Essays on art and literature. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.

Bruthiaux, P. (2002). Hold your courses: Language education, language choice, and economic development. TESOL Quarterly, 36(3), 275-296.

Chang, Y. Y. (2010). English-medium instruction for subject courses in tertiary education: Reactions from Taiwanese undergraduate students. Taiwan International ESP Journal, 2(1), 53-82.

Dearden, J. (2015). English as a medium of instruction. A growing global phenomenon. London, UK: British Council.

Erling, E. (2014). Role of English in skills development in South Asia.Retrieved from: http://oro.open.ac.uk/40430/

Evans, S. & Morrison, B. (2016): English-medium instruction in Hong Kong: Illuminating a grey area in school policies and classroom practices, Current Issues in Language Planning, Department of English, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Doi:10.1080/14664208.2016.1270106.

Gnawali, L. (2018). Teaching English in under-resourced environments. In D. Hayes (Ed.), English language teaching in Nepal: Research, reflection and practice (pp. 255-266). British Council.

Government of Nepal. (2015). Constitution of Nepal.Government of Nepal.

Haider, S., & Fang, F. (2019). Access to English in Pakistan: a source of prestige or a hindrance to success. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 39(4), 485-500.

Hall, S. (Ed.). (1997). Representation: Cultural representations and signifying practices (Vol. 2). Sage.

House, J. (2014). English as a global lingua franca: A threat to multilingual communication and translation?Language Teaching, 47(3), 363.

Hu, G., Li, L., & Lei, J. (2014). English-medium instruction at a Chinese University: Rhetoric and reality. Language Policy, 13(1), 21-40.

Kuchah, K. (2018). Early English medium instruction in Francophone Cameroon: The injustice of equal opportunity. The System, 73, 37-47.

Lareau, A., & Horvat, E. M. (1999). Moments of social inclusion and exclusion race, class, and cultural capital in family-school relationships. Sociology of education, 37-53.

Loader, I. (1997). Policing and the social: Questions of symbolic power. British Journal of Sociology, 1-18.

Ministry of Education (2010).  Multilingual education directive. Ministry of Education

Ministry of Education and Sports (MOE). (2001). Education for all: National plan of action(pp. 2001–2015). Kathmandu, Nepal: Ministry of Education and Sports.

Ministry of Education. (1971). Education act.Ministry of Education.

Ministry of Education. (1971). National Education System Plan- 1971-76. Ministry of education.

Ministry of Education. (2010). School Sector Reform Plan. Kathmandu: Government of Nepal

Phyak, P. (2016). Local-global tension in the ideological construction of English language education policy in Nepal. In English language education policy in Asia (pp. 199-17). Springer, Cham.

Phyak, P. B. (2016). Local-global tension in the ideological construction of English language education policy in Nepal. In R. Kirkpatrick (Ed.), English language education policy in Asia (pp. 199–218).New York, NY: Springer.

Poudel, T. (2019). The place of English in educational policy documents of Nepal: A critical discourse analysis. Journal of Nepalese Studies. 12 (1). Pp 112-128

Sah, P. K. (2020). English medium instruction in South Asian’s multilingual schools: unpacking the dynamics of ideological orientations, policy/practices, and democratic questions. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, Pp 1-14.

Sah, P. K., & Li, G. (2018). English medium instruction (EMI) as linguistic capital in Nepal: Promises and realities. International Multilingual Research Journal, 12(2), 109-123.

Zacharias, N. T. (2013). Navigating through the English-medium-of-instruction policy: Voices from the field. Current Issues in Language Planning, 14(1), 93-108.

 

Can be cited as: 

Mishra, D.K. & Bhatt, S. (2021, May). English medium instruction in school education: Parents’ perspectives [Blog article). ELT CHOUTARI. Available at: https://eltchoutari.com/2021/04/english-medium-instruction-in-school-education-parents-perspectives/