Tag Archives: English Language Teaching

“It Keeps the Words Come Alive”: EFL Teachers’ Perceptions and Experiences of Using Scrabble in English Language Teaching

             Hari Prasad Sapkota

Abstract

Game-based learning has gained increasing attention in English language teaching (ELT), particularly in vocabulary instruction, where playful activities can create meaningful repetition, peer interaction, and reduced anxiety. Among word games used in ELT, Scrabble has been repeatedly associated with vocabulary growth, spelling development, and learner motivation in school and higher education contexts. However, much of the existing research has focused on student achievement or classroom interventions, while teacher voice remains relatively underexplored. This study investigates the perceptions and experiences of five English as a Foreign Language (EFL) teachers who used Scrabble in their teaching. Using a qualitative design, data were generated through semi-structured interviews and analysed through reflexive thematic analysis. Four major themes emerged: Scrabble as a vocabulary and spelling scaffold; Scrabble as a motivational and low-anxiety learning space; the practical constraints of time, curriculum, and classroom management; and teacher agency in adapting the game to local pedagogical needs. The findings suggest that Scrabble is not merely an entertaining add-on, but a pedagogically valuable tool that can support lexical learning, engagement, and collaborative interaction when aligned carefully with instructional goals. At the same time, its effectiveness depends heavily on teacher facilitation, classroom conditions, and institutional flexibility. The study contributes to ELT scholarship by foregrounding teacher experience and by showing how a familiar board game can operate as a serious pedagogical resource in vocabulary-oriented classrooms.

 Keywords: Scrabble, EFL, ELT, vocabulary learning, game-based learning

 Introduction

Vocabulary is central to language learning because it underpins learners’ ability to read, listen, speak, and write with confidence and precision. In EFL classrooms, vocabulary development is often identified as one of the most persistent challenges for learners, especially where exposure to English outside the classroom is limited, and opportunities for meaningful lexical use are constrained. Although grammar has long dominated many formal language curricula, research in second language acquisition has repeatedly emphasized that without adequate vocabulary, communication breaks down even when grammatical knowledge is present (Nation, 2001). For that reason, vocabulary instruction remains a major concern in ELT research and practice. Traditional vocabulary teaching in many EFL settings still relies heavily on memorisation, translation, drilling, copying, and isolated word-list learning. These strategies may produce short-term recall, but they often fail to sustain learner interest or support long-term retention, productive use, and contextual depth of word knowledge. Vocabulary learning is not simply a matter of matching a word with its meaning; learners also need repeated exposure to spelling, pronunciation, collocation, context, and functional use. This means that effective vocabulary instruction should offer repeated, meaningful, and engaging encounters with lexical items rather than one-time presentation and testing.

One important response to these limitations has been the growing use of game-based learning. In language education, games are valued because they can transform routine learning tasks into interactive, purposeful, and motivating experiences. They provide repetition without monotony, competition without necessarily creating hostility, and communication without the full pressure of formal evaluation. In EFL classrooms, game-based learning has been linked to vocabulary retention, increased participation, stronger peer interaction, and reduced language anxiety (Madoyan, 2024; Mayer, 2019). It also offers an alternative to purely teacher-fronted instruction by allowing learners to experiment with language in more participatory and socially mediated ways.

Within this wider pedagogical landscape, Scrabble stands out as a particularly interesting tool. Scrabble is a tile-based word construction game in which players build interlocking words on a board using randomly selected letters, with points awarded according to letter value and strategic board placement. From a language teaching perspective, Scrabble combines spelling, vocabulary retrieval, lexical patterning, strategic thinking, and collaborative or competitive interaction. Unlike many paper-based vocabulary exercises, it requires learners to actively construct words rather than merely recognize them. It also invites repeated encounter with known and partially known vocabulary, making it potentially useful for both reinforcement and extension.

A growing body of post-2020 research has shown that Scrabble and Scrabble-like vocabulary games can positively affect vocabulary mastery, classroom participation, spelling accuracy, and motivation in EFL classrooms (Cahyani et al., 2024; Permana & Jumariati, 2022; Rachmawati et al., 2022). Studies in schools and university settings have reported improved learner engagement, active participation, and stronger retention when Scrabble is used either as a primary intervention or as a complementary vocabulary practice tool (Noprianto & Purnawarman, 2019; Pinandhita & Mujiyanto, 2022). Game-based learning research more broadly has also documented teachers’ positive responses to playful pedagogies when they are aligned with learning objectives and adapted to student needs (Aquino, 2026; Daulay & Adelita, 2023). Despite these encouraging findings, a major gap remains. Much of the literature has concentrated on student outcomes measured through tests, experiments, or classroom action research cycles. Far less attention has been given to what teachers think and feel about using Scrabble: how they understand its value, how they implement it, what problems they face, and how they modify the game to suit real classrooms. This is a significant omission because teachers are not passive users of pedagogical tools. Their beliefs, knowledge, creativity, and contextual judgments shape whether an activity succeeds, fails, or evolves into a sustainable part of classroom practice.

This article addresses that gap by presenting a qualitative empirical study of five EFL teachers’ perceptions and experiences of using Scrabble in ELT contexts. The focus is not simply on whether Scrabble “works,” but on how teachers interpret its pedagogical role in relation to vocabulary learning, learner motivation, classroom interaction, and practical constraints. Understanding teacher perspectives is especially important in contexts where resources are limited, class sizes are large, and curriculum pressure is intense, because under such conditions the value of a teaching tool depends not only on its theoretical promise but also on its practical usability. The study is guided by two research questions:

    1. How do EFL teachers perceive Scrabble as a pedagogical tool for vocabulary learning and language development?
    2. What experiences, challenges, and facilitation strategies do EFL teachers report when integrating Scrabble into classroom practice?

By answering these questions, the study contributes to ELT scholarship in three ways. First, it expands the literature on Scrabble in language education by moving beyond learner test scores toward teacher-centered qualitative insight. Second, it contributes to broader discussions of game-based learning by showing how a familiar and relatively low-cost analogue game can be pedagogically repurposed in meaningful ways. Third, it provides practical implications for teachers, teacher educators, and curriculum designers who want to integrate vocabulary games more systematically into ELT.

Literature Review

Vocabulary learning in EFL

Vocabulary has increasingly been recognized as a core dimension of language proficiency rather than a secondary component of grammar. Nation’s (2001) work on vocabulary learning has been especially influential in demonstrating that learners need both breadth and depth of lexical knowledge. Breadth refers to the number of words learners know, whereas depth concerns how well they know those words, including meaning, register, collocation, grammatical behavior, and contextual use. Webb and Nation (2017) later reinforced the idea that learners need repeated and meaningful encounters with lexical items if vocabulary is to move from partial recognition to fuller receptive and productive control. Research on vocabulary acquisition also highlights the value of active processing. When learners retrieve words, evaluate choices, notice form, and use vocabulary in purposeful activity, lexical learning is more durable than when vocabulary is treated as static material for memorization. Laufer and Hulstijn’s (2001) involvement load hypothesis is relevant here because it suggests that tasks promoting need, search, and evaluation support stronger vocabulary learning. Games, especially word games, often create exactly such conditions: learners feel a need to find a word, search memory or resources for alternatives, and evaluate whether a word is acceptable, strategic, and effective. Recent literature since 2020 continues to underline the importance of contextualized vocabulary learning. Studies on digital game-based language learning, gamified instruction, and incidental vocabulary acquisition through play have shown that vocabulary development is strengthened when learners interact repeatedly with words in low-stress, meaningful environments (Chowdhury et al., 2024; Janssenswillen et al., 2022; Suprapas & González-Fernández, 2026). Such work supports the pedagogical argument that vocabulary should not be confined to rote techniques, but embedded in tasks that require meaningful use, response, and interaction.

Game-based learning in ELT

Game-based learning refers to the use of complete games or structured game experiences for educational purposes. In ELT, it includes board games, card games, role-play games, online games, mobile apps, and hybrid classroom activities that integrate competition, challenge, progression, and interaction. Gamification, while related, more specifically refers to applying game elements such as points, badges, or leaderboards to non-game contexts (Deterding et al., 2011; Hamari et al., 2014). Scrabble sits closer to game-based learning than gamification because it is already a self-contained game with intrinsic rules and goals. Research in EFL contexts has repeatedly shown that game-based learning can enhance student motivation, participation, and vocabulary achievement (Cheng et al., 2025; Deci & Ryan, 2000; Mayer, 2019). Studies published after 2020 indicate that teachers generally view games positively when they are instructionally purposeful and manageable (Alwina & Iswanti, 2026; Daulay & Adelita, 2023; Permana et al., 2024). For example, research on digital and non-digital game-based learning in EFL classrooms reports greater learner engagement, reduced boredom, more active peer interaction, and stronger willingness to use English (Ling & Abdul Aziz, 2022; Cordoba et al., 2024). Studies have also noted that games can lower anxiety and encourage participation among students who are otherwise hesitant in traditional teacher-centered lessons. At the same time, the literature shows that successful implementation is not automatic. Teachers report several recurring constraints: limited class time, classroom noise, unequal learner ability, insufficient resources, and pressure to complete rigid syllabi. These findings are important because they suggest that the pedagogical value of games depends not only on learner enjoyment but also on teacher readiness, facilitation skill, and curriculum fit. The same game can function as a rich language-learning tool in one classroom and as a chaotic distraction in another, depending on how it is structured and supported.

Scrabble as a pedagogical tool

Scrabble has been used in many classrooms because it is affordable, widely recognizable, and easily adaptable. Pedagogically, it supports several language-related processes at once. First, it requires vocabulary retrieval: learners must recall words from memory rather than simply identify them from provided options. Second, it makes spelling central, because incorrectly spelled words cannot be played successfully. Third, it invites strategy and planning, as learners must consider not only word existence but also letter value, board position, and possible future moves. Fourth, it fosters interaction, since players observe, challenge, and respond to one another’s word choices. Recent studies have associated Scrabble with improved vocabulary mastery, spelling accuracy, and active classroom participation (Cahyani et al., 2024; Noprianto & Purnawarman, 2019; Rachmawati et al., 2022). Research in Indonesian and Malaysian contexts has reported gains in vocabulary learning after Scrabble-based instruction, including among school learners in resource-constrained settings (Mahendra et al., 2024; Permana & Jumariati, 2022; Sari et al., 2023). Other studies have shown that Scrabble can increase classroom enthusiasm and support more communicative engagement around vocabulary (Nugrahani, 2021; Pinandhita & Mujiyanto, 2022). Digital extensions such as Scrabble GO have also been discussed as ways to expand learning beyond the classroom and provide additional asynchronous exposure to words (Al Mirroh et al., 2024; Sundqvist & Sylvén, 2016; Tanjung & Fithriani, 2022). However, most of this literature remains outcome-centered (Wicaksono, 2023). Many studies ask whether students improved after playing Scrabble, but fewer studies ask how teachers make the activity work in practice. Yet teacher mediation matters enormously. Teachers decide whether Scrabble is used for revision, topic-specific vocabulary, spelling practice, cooperative learning, competition, assessment, or homework extension. They also decide how to group learners, when to intervene, whether to allow dictionaries, whether to use L1 strategically, and how to connect gameplay to curricular goals. A teacher-perspective study is therefore necessary to understand Scrabble not only as a game but as a classroom practice.

Teacher cognition and experience

Teacher cognition research emphasizes that teachers’ beliefs, knowledge, prior experiences, and contextual interpretations strongly shape classroom decisions (Freeman, 2016). Borg’s (2006) work is especially important in demonstrating that what teachers do in class cannot be separated from what they think, know, and believe. In the context of game-based learning, this means that the classroom use of Scrabble is not simply a matter of having a board game available. It depends on whether teachers believe it is educationally worthwhile, whether they can align it with curricular content, whether they feel confident managing it, and whether they perceive institutional support. Recent post-2020 research on teacher perceptions of game-based learning supports this point (Daulay & Adelita, 2023; Sihombing & Tambunan, 2023). Teachers commonly report that games can motivate students, encourage participation, and create a more dynamic classroom atmosphere. At the same time, they often highlight practical concerns such as time, lesson control, assessment compatibility, and training needs. This duality makes teacher perception a productive area of inquiry because it reveals not only enthusiasm but also the conditions under which enthusiasm can be sustained in real educational settings.

Theoretical framework

This study is informed by three complementary theoretical lenses (see Figure 1): Krashen’s (1982) Affective Filter Hypothesis, Vygotsky’s (1978) Zone of Proximal Development, and teacher cognition (Borg, 2006). Krashen (1982) argued that language acquisition is facilitated when learners experience low anxiety, high motivation, and a sense of confidence. When affective barriers are high, learners may fail to benefit fully from the language input available to them. Scrabble can be interpreted through this framework because it transforms vocabulary practice from formal testing into playful challenge, thereby reducing fear of error and encouraging participation. Vygotsky’s (1978) concept of the Zone of Proximal Development emphasizes that learning often occurs through interaction with more capable peers or guided support. Scrabble creates a socially mediated environment in which players observe each other, discuss possible words, challenge spellings, and learn collaboratively even within competitive play. In team formats especially, the game can become a site of peer scaffolding where learners stretch beyond what they could do independently. Finally, teacher cognition helps explain why Scrabble may be implemented differently across settings. Teachers interpret the same activity through their own pedagogical beliefs, institutional realities, and experience with learners. This framework is useful for understanding the adaptation strategies reported in the present study.

Figure 1

Theoretical Framework of the Study

 Methodology

 Research design

This study adopted a qualitative research design because the purpose was to explore teachers’ perceptions and experiences in depth rather than to measure learner outcomes statistically. A qualitative approach is appropriate when the focus is on meanings, interpretations, and contextually situated practice (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Merriam & Tisdell, 2016). Since the study sought to understand how teachers experienced Scrabble in real classroom settings, semi-structured interviewing was selected as the primary data generation method.

Participants

Five EFL teachers participated in the study. They were selected purposively (Patton, 2002) based on three criteria: they had at least three years of English teaching experience, they had used Scrabble or a Scrabble-based adaptation in their teaching, and they were willing to reflect in detail on their classroom practice. The five teachers all worked at the secondary level but came from different institutional settings: private and public schools allowing a richer range of perspectives. Pseudonyms are used to protect identity.

Pseudonym Teaching context Years of experience Level taught
Anita Private secondary school 7 Grades 8–10
Bipin Public secondary school 5 Grades 9–10
Chandani Private secondary school 9 Grades 9–10
Deepak Private secondary school 4 Grades 9–10
Elina Public secondary school 6 Grades 8–10

The participants represented different classroom conditions, including large classes, mixed-ability groups, exam-oriented contexts, and more flexible language-learning environments. This variation was valuable because it allowed the study to capture not just one version of Scrabble use, but a range of adaptations and constraints.

 Data collection and analysis

Data were generated through semi-structured individual interviews (Kvale & Brinkmann, 2009). Each interview lasted between 45 and 65 minutes. The interviews explored how teachers first began using Scrabble, why they chose it, what they believed students learned from it, what challenges they encountered, and how they adapted the game over time. Follow-up questions were used to clarify examples, encourage elaboration, and explore tensions or contradictions. Interviews were audio-recorded with participant consent and later transcribed verbatim. The semi-structured format provided consistency across interviews while still allowing participants to emphasize what mattered most in their experience. Because the focus was on perception and practice, interviewing was considered the most suitable method.

The interview transcripts were analysed through reflexive thematic analysis (Braun et al., 2022) following Braun and Clarke’s (2006) six-step approach (see Figure 2): familiarization with the data, initial coding, searching for themes, reviewing themes, defining and naming themes, and writing the report. Thematic analysis was chosen because it is flexible, well-suited to educational qualitative research, and effective for identifying patterned meaning across multiple participants.

Figure 2

The Six-Phase Process of Reflexive Thematic Analysis

Coding began with repeated reading of the transcripts and annotation of recurring ideas, tensions, and classroom issues. Initial codes included vocabulary recall, spelling awareness, excitement, shy students participating, noise, time limitation, syllabus pressure, peer support, adaptation of rules, and teacher experimentation. These codes were then grouped into broader conceptual patterns. Through iterative review, four final themes were identified.

Trustworthiness and ethics

Several steps were taken to strengthen trustworthiness (Merriam & Tisdell, 2016). First, all transcripts were read multiple times to ensure close engagement with the data. Second, emerging themes were checked against the original transcripts to avoid overgeneralization. Third, two participants were invited to comment on the interpretation of the findings, and both agreed that the analysis represented their experience fairly. Ethically, all participants gave informed consent. They were informed of the purpose of the study, their right to withdraw, and the use of pseudonyms. Data were stored securely and used only for research purposes.

 Findings

Four major themes emerged from the interviews: (1) Scrabble as a vocabulary and spelling scaffold, (2) Scrabble as a motivational and low-anxiety learning space, (3) practical constraints in implementation, and (4) teacher agency through adaptation and facilitation. These themes and their sub-themes are summarised in Figure 3.

Figure 3

Thematic Map of Teachers’ Experiences of Using Scrabble

 Scrabble as a vocabulary and spelling scaffold

All five participants described Scrabble primarily as a vocabulary-supporting activity, but their explanations went beyond the simple idea that students “learn new words.” Teachers emphasized that Scrabble helped students revisit, recall, and consolidate vocabulary they had encountered earlier but had not fully retained. In this sense, the game functioned as a scaffold for lexical activation rather than merely an entertaining break from regular instruction. Anita explained this clearly: “Sometimes they saw a word in the textbook before but forgot it. When they play Scrabble, suddenly that word comes back because they need it. It feels more alive to them because they are using it for a purpose.” This account suggests that Scrabble supports retrieval practice. Learners are not just exposed to vocabulary; they actively search memory for usable words. Such retrieval is important because repeated recall strengthens retention more effectively than passive review.

Teachers also repeatedly emphasized the role of spelling. In ordinary writing exercises, students may write quickly and pay limited attention to letter order. In Scrabble, however, spelling matters immediately because a wrong spelling makes a word unusable or open to challenge. Bipin noted: “They become more careful with letters. In writing class they sometimes guess. In Scrabble they check mentally before placing the tiles, because one mistake can cost points.” The teachers believed this visible and consequential attention to form helped students notice spelling patterns more carefully than they usually did. For students with limited confidence in English orthography, this was especially useful.

Chandani added that Scrabble also pushed some students toward independent vocabulary exploration: “A few students started learning short high-value words and unusual combinations by themselves. I didn’t assign that. The game made them curious.” This points to an important pedagogical benefit: Scrabble may stimulate autonomous lexical learning. Students sometimes move beyond classroom requirements because the game creates its own internal motivation structure. Elina and Deepak also emphasized peer-supported vocabulary learning. In mixed-ability groups, stronger students often suggested possibilities, explained meanings, or quietly supported weaker teammates. Even when the game was competitive, it still generated moments of collaborative meaning-making.

 Scrabble as a motivational and low-anxiety learning space

The second theme concerned the emotional and social atmosphere created by Scrabble. Every participant reported that Scrabble changed the mood of the classroom in ways they considered educationally beneficial. Students who were usually passive became more alert, more verbal, and more willing to take lexical risks. Elina described this effect vividly: “The students who never want to answer teacher questions become active during Scrabble. They are still shy in normal lessons, but in the game they forget that fear a little.” This is consistent with Krashen’s (1982) view that lower anxiety and higher involvement can support language acquisition. Teachers felt that Scrabble reduced the sense of being formally tested. Because students were playing, not simply performing for the teacher, the pressure of making mistakes seemed less threatening. Deepak observed a similar pattern among adult learners: “Even older students can feel embarrassed if they don’t know simple words. Scrabble changes that because everyone is working with whatever letters they get. It feels fairer, and they laugh more.” For him, the game had an equalizing function. It reduced status differences by introducing an element of chance and by shifting attention from “who is the best student” to “what can you do with these letters now?” Bipin stressed intrinsic motivation: “I don’t need to force them. The game itself is the motivation. They want to participate because it’s enjoyable.” This distinction between externally forced participation and internally driven engagement is important. Teachers did not value Scrabble only because students had fun; they valued it because fun generated effort, persistence, and attention to vocabulary. Anita described what she called productive struggle. Students stayed with the task longer, trying combinations and reconsidering choices rather than giving up quickly. From a pedagogical perspective, this persistence matters because vocabulary growth often requires sustained effort.

Practical constraints: time, curriculum, and classroom management

Although teachers valued Scrabble highly, none of them portrayed it as effortless. All five participants discussed constraints that affected how often and how deeply they could use the game. Three issues recurred most strongly: time, curriculum pressure, and classroom management. Time was the most frequently mentioned challenge. Teachers noted that a meaningful Scrabble lesson involved more than just gameplay. It required setup, explanation, playing time, and ideally some follow-up discussion or vocabulary reflection. Chandani commented: “If I only let them play, that’s not enough pedagogically. But if I include setup, play, and reflection, one class is often too short.” This meant that teachers sometimes had to choose between a richer Scrabble lesson and completing required textbook content. That choice was especially difficult in exam-oriented institutions. Anita described curriculum pressure in direct terms: “I believe in the activity, but I also have a syllabus to complete. Sometimes I use Scrabble quietly after a unit because officially there is no space for it.” Her comment suggests that innovative teaching can become semi-hidden when institutional systems value coverage more than engagement. Teachers may use a valuable tool, but only in ways that remain unofficial or limited. Classroom management was another issue, especially in larger or mixed-ability classes. Bipin explained: “With many groups, the room becomes loud. Students argue about words, ask questions, and need monitoring at the same time. It is good energy, but it is demanding energy.” Elina noted that stronger students could dominate unless roles and grouping were managed carefully. If one student always won easily, weaker students might lose interest. To solve this, she experimented with mixed groups, helper roles, and team-based formats. These findings show that Scrabble’s pedagogical value depends partly on teacher labor. The game may look simple, but effective use requires planning, monitoring, and post-game integration.

Teacher agency, adaptation, and reflective practice

The fourth theme concerned how teachers adapted Scrabble to suit curricular goals, learner profiles, and institutional conditions. None of the five teachers used the game exactly “as is” for long. Instead, they modified it in ways that reflected pedagogical reasoning and classroom experience. Anita developed what she called “Topic Scrabble,” where only words related to the current unit scored full points. She explained: “If we are studying environment, then environment words count. Otherwise, students just use any easy or high-point word they know. I wanted the game connected directly to the lesson.” This adaptation allowed her to align Scrabble with curriculum content rather than treat it as a generic vocabulary activity. Deepak created a version in which players had to define the word they placed before receiving points: “That way I know they are not just spelling a word they half-remember. They also need meaning.” This modification deepened lexical processing by combining orthographic recall with semantic articulation. It also brought speaking into the activity. Chandani used digital follow-up through Scrabble GO: “In class we use the physical board, but outside class I encourage online challenges. It keeps the words alive beyond the classroom.” This hybrid approach extended exposure time and created continuity between lessons. It also showed how analogue and digital tools can complement one another rather than compete. Elina reflected on her own learning curve: “The first time was chaotic. The next times were better because I understood what rules, grouping, and support the students needed.” Her comment highlights the importance of reflective practice. Effective game-based teaching is often learned iteratively through experimentation, adjustment, and growing confidence.

 Discussion

The findings of this study show that Scrabble occupies an interesting position in ELT. Teachers perceived it neither as a trivial pastime nor as a magical solution, but as a powerful tool whose educational value emerges when it is purposefully mediated. This section discusses the findings in relation to existing literature and the theoretical framework.

First, the finding that teachers saw Scrabble as a vocabulary and spelling scaffold aligns strongly with vocabulary acquisition theory. The game creates repeated opportunities for lexical retrieval, evaluation, and reuse. This supports the idea that vocabulary learning is strengthened by active processing rather than passive recognition (Laufer & Hulstijn, 2001; Nation, 2001). Teachers’ observations that students recalled previously encountered words and became more attentive to spelling are consistent with research showing that game-based vocabulary tasks can enhance both lexical retention and orthographic awareness (Cahyani et al., 2024; Rachmawati et al., 2022).

Second, the affective benefits reported by teachers support Krashen’s (1982) Affective Filter Hypothesis. Students who were usually hesitant became more active and more willing to engage in English during Scrabble. Teachers interpreted this change not simply as enjoyment, but as a reduction in fear. This suggests that Scrabble helps create a psychologically safer learning environment where participation feels less risky. Such an environment is particularly valuable in EFL contexts where fear of error often suppresses classroom interaction.

Third, the findings support Vygotskian perspectives (Vygotsky, 1978) on socially mediated learning. Even in competitive formats, Scrabble generated moments of peer scaffolding, lexical negotiation, and shared problem solving. Teachers described stronger students supporting weaker peers, group members discussing possible words, and classmates challenging or explaining spellings. These are precisely the kinds of interactions through which language learning can be stretched beyond solitary performance.

Fourth, the study reinforces the importance of teacher cognition (Borg, 2006). Participants did not simply apply Scrabble mechanically. They interpreted its strengths and limits, modified its rules, aligned it with instructional goals, and reflected on its classroom fit. This confirms that the educational value of a tool depends significantly on teacher agency. Scrabble became pedagogically meaningful because teachers transformed it from a recreational board game into a structured language-learning event.

The findings also reveal the structural conditions that may limit game-based learning. Time pressure, syllabus demands, and classroom management concerns were not minor inconveniences; they shaped what teachers could realistically do. This is consistent with recent literature showing that positive teacher attitudes toward games do not automatically translate into frequent or sustained classroom use. Institutional support, curriculum flexibility, and practical teacher preparation remain crucial.

An important implication of the present study is that low-cost analogue games still deserve serious scholarly attention. In current educational discourse, digital innovation often receives greater visibility. Yet Scrabble shows that non-digital tools can remain pedagogically rich, especially in contexts where access to technology is limited. Moreover, analogue games may offer social and tactile dimensions that support interaction differently from digital platforms. At the same time, the teachers’ use of digital extensions such as Scrabble GO suggests that the most productive future direction may not be a binary choice between analogue and digital modes, but thoughtful integration of both. Physical Scrabble can support in-class interaction, while digital formats can extend vocabulary engagement beyond the lesson. This hybrid perspective deserves further research.

Implications

Teachers who wish to use Scrabble in ELT should consider it most effective when linked clearly to learning goals. Topic-based adaptations, vocabulary follow-up tasks, group rules, and meaning checks can make the game more pedagogically focused. Teachers should also anticipate management issues in advance by planning group size, time limits, role distribution, and language-use expectations. Teacher education programs should not treat game-based learning as self-explanatory. Teachers may need support in selecting games, adapting rules, connecting play to curriculum outcomes, and managing classroom dynamics (Ragni et al., 2023). Practical workshops using real classroom scenarios could help teachers move from abstract approval of games to confident implementation. Curriculum designers and school leaders should recognize that game-based vocabulary learning can be academically serious. If curriculum frameworks allow space for structured lexical play, teachers are more likely to use such activities openly and systematically. Recognition in lesson planning and assessment policy would reduce the tension between innovation and syllabus coverage.

Conclusion

This study explored five EFL teachers’ perceptions and experiences of using Scrabble in English language teaching. The findings show that teachers view Scrabble as a valuable vocabulary and spelling scaffold, a strong source of learner engagement, and a tool that can reduce anxiety and support peer interaction. At the same time, they experience real constraints related to time, curriculum demands, and classroom management. Their responses to these constraints reveal considerable professional agency, as they adapt the game to fit local goals and classroom realities. Overall, Scrabble emerges from this study as more than a recreational activity. In the hands of thoughtful teachers, it becomes a flexible and meaningful pedagogical resource. Its educational value lies not only in the game itself, but in the interaction between game structure, teacher facilitation, and learner participation. By centering teacher voice, this article contributes to a fuller understanding of how vocabulary games function in ELT practice. This study involved only five teachers, so its findings are not statistically generalizable. However, the goal of the study was depth rather than breadth, and the rich accounts provided by participants offer useful insight into classroom practice. Future research could extend this work by observing Scrabble lessons directly, interviewing students, comparing analogue and digital Scrabble formats, or examining long-term vocabulary development in Scrabble-integrated classrooms. Larger multi-site qualitative studies would also help clarify how institutional context shapes teacher uptake of game-based learning.

The author:

Hari Prasad Sapkota is a TEFL-certified international English language teacher with over 14 years of experience teaching both national and international students. He holds an MA in English Literature from Tribhuvan University and an MPhil in English Language Education from the School of Education, Kathmandu University, Nepal. His research interests include differentiated instruction, English language teaching, contemplative pedagogy, and philosophy. Email: sapkotah2@gmail.com

References

Al Mirroh, D., Asyhar, W. I., & Kurniawan, E. H. (2024). Analyzing of Scrabble Go application as a media of English language teaching. IDEAS: Journal on English Language Teaching and Learning, Linguistics and Literature, 12(2), 3276–3286. https://doi.org/10.24256/ideas.v12i2.6135

Alwina, M. I., & Iswanti, E. (2026). Exploring teachers’ perceptions of game-based learning in English classrooms: A case study at a private elementary school. Journal of English Language and Educational Studies, 1(1), 1–15. https://journalng.uwks.ac.id/jeles/article/view/1093

Aquino, M. A. (2026). Vocabulary acquisition through gamification strategy: Elementary teachers’ narratives. EPRA International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research. https://eprajournals.com/IJMR/article/20217

Borg, S. (2006). Teacher cognition and language education: Research and practice. Continuum.

Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa

Braun, V., Clarke, V., Hayfield, N., & Terry, G. (2022). Thematic analysis: A practical guide. SAGE.

Cahyani, N. L. W., Utami, I. G. A. L. P., & Agustini, D. A. E. (2024). Game-based learning assisted by Scrabble: Vocabulary mastery of seventh grade students. Innovative: Journal of Social Science Research, 4(1). https://doi.org/10.31004/innovative.v4i1

Cheng, J., Lu, C., & Xiao, Q. (2025). Effects of gamification on EFL learning: A quasi-experimental study of reading proficiency and language enjoyment among Chinese undergraduates. Frontiers in Psychology, 16, 1448916. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1448916

Chowdhury, M., Dixon, L. Q., Kuo, L.-J., Donaldson, J. P., Eslami, Z., Viruru, R., & Luo, W. (2024). Digital game-based language learning for vocabulary development. Computers and Education Open, 6, 100160. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.caeo.2024.100160

Cordoba, E., Mayorga, E., & Ruiz, N. (2024). Unlocking practical implications of digital game-based learning in EFL education. International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 23(12). https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.23.12.2

Creswell, J. W., & Poth, C. N. (2018). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches (4th ed.). SAGE.

Daulay, S. H., & Adelita, D. (2023). Using Scrabble as a gamification to enhance students’ motivation and vocabulary acquisition: Teachers’ perspective. Metathesis: Journal of English Language, Literature, and Teaching, 7(1), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.31002/metathesis.v7i1.150

Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The “what” and “why” of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327965PLI1104_01

Deterding, S., Dixon, D., Khaled, R., & Nacke, L. (2011). From game design elements to gamefulness: Defining gamification. In Proceedings of the 15th International Academic MindTrek Conference (pp. 9–15). https://doi.org/10.1145/2181037.2181040

Freeman, D. (2016). Educating second language teachers. Oxford University Press.

Hamari, J., Koivisto, J., & Sarsa, H. (2014). Does gamification work? A literature review of empirical studies on gamification. In Proceedings of the 47th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (pp. 3025–3034). https://doi.org/10.1109/HICSS.2014.377

Janssenswillen, P., Vanbuel, M., & Peters, E. (2022). Factors affecting incidental L2 vocabulary acquisition and retention from digital games. Studies in Second Language Acquisition.

Krashen, S. D. (1982). Principles and practice in second language acquisition. Pergamon Press.

Kvale, S., & Brinkmann, S. (2009). InterViews: Learning the craft of qualitative research interviewing (2nd ed.). SAGE.

Laufer, B., & Hulstijn, J. (2001). Incidental vocabulary acquisition in a second language: The construct of task-induced involvement. Applied Linguistics, 22(1), 1–26. https://doi.org/10.1093/applin/22.1.1

Ling, N. S., & Abdul Aziz, A. (2022). The effectiveness of game-based learning strategies on primary ESL learners’ vocabulary learning. International Journal of Academic Research in Progressive Education and Development, 11(2), 845–860. https://doi.org/10.6007/IJARPED/v11-i2/13266

Madoyan, L. (2024). Gamification and student motivation in EFL classroom. Foreign Languages for Special Purposes, 23, 169–182. https://doi.org/10.46991/FLSP.2024.23.169

Mahendra, J. W., Maghfiroh, A., Harmanto, B., & Hatmoko, D. (2024). The effectiveness of Scrabble games to promote vocabulary achievement of migrant workers’ children in Malaysia. Journal of Languages and Language Teaching, 12(2), 963–973. https://doi.org/10.33394/jollt.v12i2.10478

Mayer, R. E. (2019). Computer games in education. Annual Review of Psychology, 70, 531–549. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-010418-102744

Merriam, S. B., & Tisdell, E. J. (2016). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.

Nation, I. S. P. (2001). Learning vocabulary in another language. Cambridge University Press.

Noprianto, E., & Purnawarman, P. (2019). Scrabble game and EFL students’ vocabulary enhancement. Journal of Foreign Language Teaching and Learning, 4(1), 27–45. https://doi.org/10.18196/ftl.4129

Nugrahani, Y. F. (2021). Perspectives on the use of Scrabble as media to teach vocabulary [Undergraduate thesis, UIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya]. http://digilib.uinsa.ac.id/50925/

Patton, M. Q. (2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods (3rd ed.). SAGE.

Permana, I. G. Y., Rismadewi, N. W. M., & Adi Putra, N. C. (2024). Gamification in EFL classroom: Results of implementation and teachers’ point of view. UTAMAX: Journal of Ultimate Research and Trends in Education, 6(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.31849/utamax.v6i1.19297

Permana, T. I., & Jumariati, J. (2022). Teaching vocabulary using Scrabble: Students’ responses and vocabulary improvement. Jurnal Pendidikan dan Pengajaran, 55(1), 107–116.

Pinandhita, R. A., & Mujiyanto, J. (2022). The use of Scrabble game in teaching vocabulary. English Education Journal, 12(3), 358–367.

Rachmawati, T., Emzir, E., & Rafli, Z. (2022). Scrabble game: Boosting vocabulary mastery of English foreign language (EFL) students. Journal of English Education and Technology, 12(2), 45–56.

Ragni, B., Toto, G. A., di Furia, M., Lavanga, A., & Limone, P. (2023). The use of Digital Game-Based Learning (DGBL) in teachers’ training: A scoping review. Frontiers in Education, 8, 1092022. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2023.1092022

Sari, D. F., Yusuf, Y. Q., Wahyuni, S., & Kangkha, P. (2023). Improving EFL students’ vocabulary in a rural area through Scrabble with crossword picture puzzle. Journal of English Education and Teaching, 7(2), 429–439. https://doi.org/10.33369/jeet.7.2.429-439

Sihombing, P. S. M., & Tambunan, A. R. S. (2023). Teachers’ perceptions of digital game-based vocabulary learning. Linguistik Terapan, 20(1), 84–94. https://doi.org/10.24114/lt.v20i1.46634

Sundqvist, P., & Sylvén, L. K. (2016). Extramural English in teaching and learning. Palgrave Macmillan.

Suprapas, I., & González-Fernández, B. (2026). Incidental vocabulary learning through gaming: An exploratory study in an extramural context. ITL – International Journal of Applied Linguistics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1075/itl.25017.sup

Tanjung, A. P., & Fithriani, R. (2022). Integrating Scrabble online as a tool to support vocabulary learning. Scope: Journal of English Language Teaching. https://journal.lppmunindra.ac.id/index.php/SCOPE/article/view/17699

Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Harvard University Press.

Webb, S., & Nation, I. S. P. (2017). How vocabulary is learned. Oxford University Press.

Wicaksono, J. T. (2023). The use of Scrabble word game in English language teaching (ELT): A meta-synthesis [Master’s thesis, UIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya]. http://digilib.uinsa.ac.id/80783/

English as a Medium of Instruction in Nepal: A Critical Review of Dr. Prem Phyak’s Interview, Shiksha Bimarsha: Angreji Madhyam Ra Yasle Shikshan Sikaima Pareko Prabhav

           Khem Raj Rauteda

Abstract

The growing adoption of English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) in Nepal has generated extensive debate regarding its educational, linguistic, and social implications. This paper critically reviews the interview शिक्षा विमर्श : अंग्रेजी माध्यम र यसले शिक्षण सिकाइमा पार्ने प्रभाव | Interview with Prem Fhyak – YouTube featuring Dr. Prem Phyak, which examines the emergence of EMI, the ideologies supporting its implementation, and its consequences for teaching and learning in Nepal’s multilingual context. The review summarizes the key arguments presented in the interview and critically analyzes them through relevant educational, sociolinguistic, and philosophical perspectives. It discusses concerns related to language policy, learners’ comprehension, identity, educational equity, and the gap between policy and classroom practice. The paper further examines the interview through decolonial theory, critical pedagogy, Marxist perspectives, and multilingual approaches to understand the broader implications of EMI for language, power, and social justice. Particular attention is given to the advocacy of mother tongue-based multilingual education and translanguaging as pedagogical alternatives that recognize learners’ linguistic resources and promote more inclusive learning environments. The review concludes that the interview provides a timely and thought-provoking critique of EMI in Nepal and highlights the need for language policies and educational practices that are responsive to the country’s multilingual realities and committed to educational equity.

Keywords: English as a Medium of Instruction, multilingual education, language policy, translanguaging, Nepal, critical review

Introduction

The increasing adoption of English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) has become one of the most debated issues in Nepalese education. While EMI is often associated with educational quality, global competitiveness, and social mobility, it has also generated concerns regarding learners’ comprehension, linguistic rights, educational equity, and the role of local languages in multilingual classrooms (Rauteda, 2024a; Rauteda & Luitel, 2025). These debates have drawn the attention of scholars, educators, and policymakers who continue to question the appropriateness and consequences of EMI in Nepal’s linguistically diverse context.

Against this backdrop, this paper critically reviews the interview titled Shiksha Bimarsha: Angreji Madhyam ra Yasle Shikshan Sikaima Pareko Prabhav, published on the ‘Nepalkhabar YouTube channel’ on 30 May 2024. The interview, conducted by Roshna Subba with Dr. Prem Phyak, Associate Professor at Columbia University, New York, and former Head of the Department of English Education at Tribhuvan University, discusses the historical development of EMI, the ideologies underpinning its implementation, its practices in Nepal, and the relevance of multilingual education in addressing the country’s linguistic diversity.

The purpose of this review is to critically examine the major arguments presented in the interview by situating them within relevant educational, sociolinguistic, and philosophical perspectives. In doing so, the paper highlights the implications of EMI for teaching, learning, language policy, and educational justice while discussing the potential of Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) and translanguaging as alternative pedagogical approaches in Nepalese classrooms.

Overview of the Interview

The interview primarily discusses the implications of EMI in the Nepalese education system, with particular attention to its relevance in a multilingual society (Phyak, 2021; 2023). At the outset, Dr. Prem Phyak argues that teaching children through a language unfamiliar to them creates barriers to meaningful learning, as learners are unable to express themselves freely in their native languages (Phyak, 2021). He emphasizes that language plays a fundamental role in children’s learning and identity formation, particularly at the primary level (Phyak, 2023).

The discussion traces the historical emergence and expansion of EMI in both global and Nepalese contexts and examines the major ideologies that have supported its adoption. It explores the reasons behind the increasing implementation of EMI in Nepal, including assumptions regarding educational quality, competitiveness, and social aspirations. The interview also highlights the discrepancy between language policy and classroom practice, questioning the effectiveness of EMI in multilingual classrooms where learners and teachers possess diverse linguistic backgrounds.

A substantial part of the interview focuses on the educational, social, and linguistic implications of EMI. Dr. Phyak argues that the widespread use of English as the sole medium of instruction may limit learner participation, reduce opportunities for meaningful classroom interaction, and marginalize learners’ home languages. This idea of Dr. Phyak has also been advocated in his own empirical studies, such as (Phyak, 2021; 2023), and in some other scholars’ works, such as (Rauteda, 2024a; Rauteda & Luitel, 2025). The discussion further addresses the symbolic value of English in Nepalese society and its influence on educational practices and language ideologies.

The interview concludes by advocating MTB-MLE as a more appropriate approach for Nepal’s multilingual context. It also introduces multilingual pedagogical practices, particularly translanguaging, as a means of utilizing learners’ full linguistic repertoires to support teaching and learning. Throughout the discussion, the interview emphasizes the importance of developing language policies and classroom practices that are responsive to Nepal’s linguistic diversity and educational realities.

Critical Analysis of the Interview

In the interview, Phyak contended that language-related issues have not been adequately addressed in Nepal. Current language policies and educational language planning fail to reflect the country’s multilingual context, where 124 languages are spoken (NSO, 2021). Phyak emphasized the significance of language in learning, particularly at the foundational levels, advocating for mother tongue-based multilingual education (MTB-MLE). Such an approach fosters an open and supportive environment that encourages learners to become critical, creative, and innovative thinkers. He further argued that teaching in a language other than the learners’ mother tongue imposes a cognitive burden, diminishing learner engagement. Supporting his argument, Rauteda (2025a) states that teaching solely using the English language in the classroom, avoiding learners’ home languages, creates disengagement and demotivation. Although English is frequently used as the medium of instruction in Nepal’s educational system, this practice restricts learners’ potential and overlooks transformative aspects of education. Phyak also highlighted the importance of multilingual education for facilitating interaction, encouraging inquiry, and promoting social transformation and justice.

Referencing neurological linguistics and research on language teaching and learning, the speaker advocated for MTB-MLE, arguing that EMI restricts children’s potential. The speaker emphasized the social, cultural, political, and economic challenges created by using a foreign language as the medium of instruction. A key point raised was that fostering a sense of belonging is crucial for effective learning, which is achievable only when children are taught in their mother tongue. In this regard, Rauteda (2025a) says that learners’ sense of belonging can only be assured when their linguistic repertoire is allowed to be used in the classrooms. Furthermore, the speaker argued that language is intrinsically linked to identity, and children may experience a loss of safety and pride if they are not exposed to their family language. Thus, MTB-MLE is framed as a decolonial practice, challenging monolingual ideologies. The speaker also drew upon Foucault’s ideas of language and power, linking them to educational language planning and policy, where only so-called standard languages hold dominance, while others are marginalized. Additionally, language was portrayed as a tool that can perpetuate the colonization of other languages, cultures, and systems over time.

The interviewer then raised a question regarding the EMI context, to which Dr. Phyak responded by contextualizing EMI, echoing Dearden’s (2014) perspective. He explained that EMI refers to a situation where English is not spoken at home, nor in the neighborhood, with siblings, nor used as a contact language. However, content subjects such as science, mathematics, and other disciplinary areas are taught in English. Dr. Phyak further expanded on the broader discourse in language teaching, distinguishing between ‘learning a language’ and ‘learning through a language,’ emphasizing that these are fundamentally different processes.

The speaker highlighted several hegemonic aspects of EMI, using examples such as the designation of ‘English Speaking Zones’ in private school settings. This linguistic landscape, according to the speaker, is indicative of the presence of English imperialism within the medium of instruction. Addressing different EMI contexts, the speaker noted that in some schools where EMI is implemented alongside other languages, hierarchical structures have emerged. These practices, the speaker argued, have exacerbated inequalities and perpetuated injustice in educational environments, widening the gap between elites and ordinary citizens. Drawing on Marx’s concept of class, the speaker suggested that EMI has created class distinctions in schools, with English being associated with the elite. Additionally, research has shown that English is viewed as a language of power, prestige, and social capital, resonating with Bourdieu’s (1986) notion of linguistic capital.

Phyak explained that the adoption of EMI initially began in private schools and was later extended to public schools in the name of enhancing quality education and fostering competition. The discussion further explored the underlying ideologies supporting EMI, including the aims of increasing student enrollment, fulfilling parental aspirations, improving educational quality, and promoting internationalization (Rauteda, 2024a). However, Phyak expressed his dissent regarding these ideologies, arguing that they are based on misconceptions and misunderstandings. Additionally, the discussion revealed that many schools abandoned EMI after failing to achieve the anticipated outcomes.

Phyak highlighted a significant issue with the implementation of EMI, pointing out the paradox that stakeholders are unable to provide a sufficient number of English subject teachers while expecting all subjects to be taught in English. He argued that this discrepancy reveals a critical problem, particularly at the primary level, where subject-specific teachers are in short supply. Phyak emphasized that the low proficiency of teachers in English exacerbates the challenges of EMI. He asserted that EMI impedes both student learning and teacher effectiveness, limiting educational outcomes and stifling students’ critical thinking and creativity. Furthermore, Phyak argued that EMI hampers the construction of knowledge, rendering students’ passive and diminishing their capacity for critical analysis.

The speaker contended that learning extends beyond merely passing exams and understanding the prescribed curriculum; it involves applying knowledge to solve real-life problems and connecting with the community. He argued that learning English should not be viewed as an end in itself, but rather as a means to acquire skills and create space for further learning, provided that teachers deliver effective compulsory English instruction. Phyak cited reports from UNESCO, the British Council, and the World Bank, noting that approximately 37-40 percent of students show low achievement in learning due to the medium of instruction. He also addressed the belief held by some schools and stakeholders that studying in the Nepali medium undermines the strength of learners, schools, and institutions. Phyak critiqued this view as a deficit ideology towards Nepali medium education.

The speaker argued that public schools have not critically examined the situation; instead, they have accepted the policy at face value. He further stated that the preparation at the policy level is insufficient for effectively implementing EMI. Additionally, he pointed out that stakeholders are not taking the social, political, and economic impacts of the policy. Interestingly, the speaker considers this policy to be a form of educational waste, as learners struggle to grasp the intended material because of the EMI. He suggests that this issue arises from the symbolic value of the English language in social, political, and economic contexts.

Phyak seems to be positioning himself as a decolonial thinker and suggests being separated from the EMI, saying not to be bound with the language. He asked for a safe environment where the subject position of the learners is to be respected and addressed.  Showing the gap in policy and practice, he said that we are in ‘hauguji’ (imagined fear) in languaging. Moreover, the speaker said that the policy-makers are not serious about the classes that the policy has created in the schools and the community. Appealing for multilingual education, he said that multilingualism has been taken as a problem in the Nepalese schools, but it is a resource and should be utilized as an asset in the multilingual classroom for justice in diversity. The idea regarding multilingualism as a resource has been empirically justified by some studies, such as (Phyak, 2018; Rauteda, 2022; Rauteda, 2024b; Rauteda, 2025a; Rauteda, 2025b; Rauteda, 2026a). Moreover, he presented the idea that students are not the deficit object. Instead, they can perform well if they get the chance to be exposed in their mother tongue. Further, multilingual pedagogical activities are to be employed in the classroom for the cognitive, metacognitive, and metalinguistic abilities. He gave one example of multilingual pedagogical activities, i.e., ‘translanguaging’ where speakers can receive information in one language and produce in another language (Williams, 2002), and use more than two language abilities simultaneously, naturally, dynamically, and purposefully (Garcia, 2009; Phyak, 2018; Rauteda, 2022; Rauteda, 2024b). To the community of practice, Phyak suggested that teachers should have critical multilingual awareness, where empowerment of the learners is to be the central concern. So, the policy makers and practitioners should be critically aware of the ground reality of the society, thinking about the long-term effects of any policy.

Philosophical and Theoretical Stances on the Interview

The talk has been critically analyzed from different lenses or philosophical perspectives. Hence, I attempted to see the ideas based on the following philosophical views;

Decolonial Perspectives and Language Ideologies

In the interview, Phyak argues that EMI perpetuates educational and social inequalities in Nepal, an assertion that aligns closely with decolonial frameworks. This perspective reflects the foundational work of decolonial scholars such as Ngũgĩ (1986), who contends that language is not merely a communicative tool but a primary vehicle for culture, identity, and institutional power. Framed through this lens, Phyak’s interview narrative positions EMI as a continuation of colonial practices, wherein English—historically an instrument of imperial domination—has been repurposed as a contemporary marker of elitism and socio-economic privilege. Furthermore, Phyak’s call during the interview to resist dominant monolingual ideologies that marginalize local languages represents a direct challenge to the preservation of these historical power asymmetries in education (Phyak, 2021). This critique intersects with Foucault’s (1980) theorization of discourse, which demonstrates how language and knowledge function as regulatory instruments of institutional power and social control. By advocating for MTB-MLE throughout the interview, Phyak proposes a decolonial approach to schooling that actively critiques the hegemony of Western linguistic and knowledge systems. Because language policy dictates who holds the authority to speak and in what manner, it functions as a mechanism of social exclusion (Foucault, 1980). Ultimately, Phyak’s interview characterization of EMI as a catalyst for compounding social, cultural, and political challenges underscores how macro-level language policies can inadvertently reinforce elite dominance over marginalized populations (Phyak, 2023).

Critical Pedagogy and Social Justice

Phyak’s interview reflections align closely with Paulo Freire’s (1970) framework of critical pedagogy, which positions education as a mechanism for empowering marginalized populations and advancing social justice. Freire’s (1970) conceptualization of “banking education”—wherein students serve as passive recipients of top-down knowledge—parallels Phyak’s critique of EMI, which he argues imposes severe cognitive and participatory barriers on learners. According to the interview narrative, the systemic exclusion of mother-tongue instruction, particularly in primary schooling, inherently obstructs students’ capacity for critical engagement, constrains their creative agency, and ultimately reinforces existing social hierarchies (Phyak, 2023). Furthermore, Phyak’s discussion of the marginalization of Nepal’s indigenous languages through EMI exemplifies the dynamics of symbolic violence, a concept established by Pierre Bourdieu (1991). Central to this analysis is Bourdieu’s (1991) notion of “linguistic capital.” In the interview, Phyak illustrates how English functions as a dominant linguistic market asset, granting access to institutional power, prestige, and upward socio-economic mobility within Nepalese society. However, as Phyak underscores, this reliance on EMI compounds class distinctions; it systematically privileges affluent demographics with the resources to navigate elite educational spaces, while structurally marginalizing students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds who remain reliant on their primary indigenous languages (Phyak, 2021).

Marxist Class Analysis

Phyak’s observation during the interview that EMI constructs distinct “classes within schools” aligns closely with Marxist frameworks of class struggle. Within a Marxist paradigm, institutional mechanisms—including language policies—frequently function as instruments of the ruling class to regulate access to economic, social, and political resources (Marx & Engels, 1970). By prioritizing English, the Nepalese educational system entrenches a systemic class stratification; socio-economic elites with the means to access high-quality English education consolidate their structural power, while ordinary citizens are left structurally disadvantaged (Phyak, 2023). This stratification connects directly with Gramsci’s (1971) formulation of cultural hegemony, which posits that a dominant class maintains control not merely through coercive material force, but through ideological apparatuses, including formal schooling. According to the interview narrative, the pervasive emphasis on EMI across both public and private educational sectors perpetuates this hegemonic control. Phyak argues that by positioning English as the exclusive language of modern success, the state effectively manufactures consent for a system that marginalizes indigenous languages and devalues local epistemic frameworks (Phyak, 2021).

Multilingualism and Translanguaging as Resistance

Phyak’s advocacy for multilingualism, particularly his reference to translanguaging (Garcia, 2009; Williams, 2002), offers a way to resist linguistic and cultural domination. Translanguaging challenges the traditional boundaries between languages, allowing for a more fluid and dynamic use of multiple languages in the classroom (Garcia & Wei, 2014). This pedagogical practice reflects a decolonial approach, as it legitimizes the use of local languages in education, promoting equity and cognitive development. By encouraging the use of students’ full linguistic repertoire, translanguaging fosters a more inclusive and empowering learning environment, countering the monolingual dominance of EMI (Rauteda, 2025a; Rauteda, 2026b). Phyak’s emphasis on critical multilingual awareness also connects to the work of critical sociolinguists, who argue that language practices in education should reflect the multilingual realities of students’ lives (Makoni & Pennycook, 2007). The imposition of a single language of instruction, such as English, not only erases linguistic diversity but also denies students the cognitive and cultural resources embedded in their native languages.

Conclusion

This critical review of Dr. Prem Phyak’s interview illuminates the deep-seated ideological, socio-economic, and pedagogical contradictions underpinning the uncritical expansion of EMI in Nepal. Far from being a neutral vehicle for global competitiveness or educational quality, EMI functions as a structural mechanism that reproduces systemic inequalities. When evaluated through decolonial, Marxist, and critical pedagogical lenses, the pervasive imposition of English-only policies operates as an apparatus of cultural hegemony and symbolic violence. It alienates learners from their primary linguistic identities, strips them of their creative agency by enforcing a restrictive form of ‘banking education’, and entrenches deep class stratifications within the Nepalese educational landscape. Conversely, Phyak’s advocacy for MTB-MLE and translanguaging offers a transformative, decolonial pathway forward. By dismantling monolingual biases and re-centering the classroom around the child’s native linguistic repertoire, these approaches re-conceptualize multilingualism as an invaluable educational resource rather than a systemic deficit. Implementing these pluralistic pedagogical frameworks allows schools to foster genuine cognitive development, preserve indigenous cultural heritages, and promote democratic participation.

Ultimately, this review underscores that the current disconnect between top-down language planning and classroom realities cannot be resolved by superficial policy mandates. Instead, it requires a radical shift toward critical multilingual awareness among policymakers, educators, and local communities. For Nepal to achieve genuine educational equity and social justice, its schooling systems must divest from the homogenizing forces of linguistic imperialism and actively embrace policies that are authentically responsive to the country’s rich, historical multilingual realities.

The author:

Khem Raj Rauteda is an ELT researcher, teacher, and teacher educator currently pursuing his M.Phil. at the Graduate School of Education, Tribhuvan University. He is also a Lecturer at Janta Multiple Campus, Itahari, Sunsari.

Email: krauteda@gmail.com
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5869-7304

References

Bourdieu, P. (1986). The Forms of Capital. In J. Richardson (Ed.), Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education (pp. 241–258). Greenwood.

Bourdieu, P. (1991). Language and symbolic power (G. Raymond & M. Adamson, Trans.; J. B. Thompson, Ed.). Harvard University Press.

Dearden, J. (2014). English as a Medium of Instruction – A Growing Global Phenomenon. British Council.

Foucault, M. (1972). The Archaeology of Knowledge. Pantheon Books.

Foucault, M. (1980). Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977. Pantheon Books.

Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Herder and Herder.

Garcia, O. & Wei, L. (2014). Translanguaging: Language, bilingualism and education. Palgrave.

Garcia, O. (2009). Bilingual Education in the 21st Century: A Global Perspective. Wiley-Blackwell.

Gramsci, A. (1971). Selections from the prison notebooks (Q. Hoare & G. N. Smith, Eds. & Trans.). International Publishers.

Makoni, S., & Pennycook, A. (2007). Disinventing and Reconstituting Languages. Multilingual Matters.

Marx, K., & Engels, F. (1970). The German ideology (C. J. Arthur, Ed.). International Publishers.

National Statistics Office. (2021). National population and housing census 2021 results. Government of Nepal.

Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o. (1986). Decolonising the Mind: The Politics of Language in African Literature. Heinemann Educational.

Phyak, P. (2021). Language education policy in Nepal and the denial of the right to speak in Indigenous languages. Melbourne Asia Review, 7. https://doi.org/10.37839/mar2652-550×7.7

Phyak, P. (2023). Producing the disciplined English-speaking subjects: Language policing, development ideology, and English medium of instruction policy. Language in Society, 53(2), 321–343. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0047404523000052

Rauteda, K. (2026b). Translanguaging in English as a Medium of Instruction (EMI) content classrooms: Unfolding the teachers’ narratives. IJIET (International Journal of Indonesian Education and Teaching), 10(2), 200-216. https://doi.org/10.24071/ijiet.v10i2.14291

Rauteda, K. R. (2022). Translanguaging as a pedagogical resource in multilingual ELT classrooms: Exploring perceptions and practices [Master’s Thesis]. Tribhuvan University.

Rauteda, K. R. (2024a). Use of EMI at secondary education: Exploring non-English Nepalese teachers’ ideologies. Siddhajyoti Interdisciplinary Journal, 5(1), 33-43. https://doi.org/10.3126/sij.v5i1.63596

Rauteda, K. R. (2024b). Unveiling pedagogical translanguaging: Investigating teachers’ translingual practices and purposes in ELT classrooms. English Language Teaching Perspectives, 9(1-2), 51–66. https://doi.org/10.3126/eltp.v9i1-2.68719

Rauteda, K. R. (2025a). Translanguaging for transformation: Identity, equity, and pedagogical resistance in Nepalese ELT classrooms. Indonesian Journal of English Language Studies (IJELS), 11(2), 150-162. https://doi.org/10.24071/ijels.v11i2.12202

Rauteda, K. R. (2026a). Linguistic hybridity in Nepalese ELT classrooms: A narrative inquiry into English language teachers’ beliefs and practices. Journal of Janta Multiple Campus, 5(1), 147-170. https://doi.org/10.3126/jjmc.v5i1.97994

Rauteda, K. R., & Luitel, B. (2025). Teachers’ pedagogical resistance of EMI through classroom translanguaging in Nepalese science classrooms. IJIET (International Journal of Indonesian Education and Teaching), 9(2), 441-456. https://doi.org/10.24071/ijiet.v9i2.12043

Rauteda, K.R. (2025b). Enhancing Learner Engagement through Translanguaging Pedagogy: A Reflective Narrative from a Multilingual ELT Classroom in Nepal [Blog article]. ELT Choutari. Available at: https://eltchoutari.com/2025/11/enhancing-learner-engagement-throughtranslanguaging-pedagogy-a-reflective-narrative-from-a-multilingual-eltclassroom-in-nepal/

Williams, C. (2002). Extending Bilingualism in the Education System.

English Teachers’ Practices in Teaching Writing Skills at the Secondary Level: A Study of Community Schools in Rolpa District

          Chandra Prakash Oli

Abstract

This brief study explored the perceptions and classroom practices of secondary English teachers in teaching writing skills in public schools. Using a qualitative approach, I purposively selected four in-service English teachers from four public schools in Rolpa district. Data were collected through unstructured interviews and classroom observations. The findings reveal that teachers hold a positive view of writing instruction and actively apply key strategies—such as controlled, guided, and free writing, alongside process and genre-based approaches—in their classrooms. They perceive they invest their effort to make the teaching of writing as effective as possible, however, classroom realities reveal a significant disconnect between their beliefs and actual practices.

Introduction

Second language learning encompasses four primary skills: listening, speaking, reading, and writing. The development of second language acquisition primarily begins with listening, as it is the first receptive skill to develop in human beings (Renukadevi, 2014). At the initial stage of the second language learning process, learners listen to the target language and gradually learn to read and write, progressing from the English alphabet to words and complete sentences.

To understand the nature of writing, it is necessary to examine the taxonomy of writing. According to Jacobs et al. (1981) and Hall (1988), this taxonomy includes mechanics (spelling and punctuation), vocabulary, grammar, syntax, organization, cohesion, coherence, content, and diction (word selection), all of which must be appropriate to the audience, topic, and occasion. Fundamentally, letters are combined to form words, and words are arranged to form sentences. These sentences are then grouped into paragraphs to develop coherent ideas, making paragraphs the expanded structural units of sentences.

Byrne (1988) asserts that writing is not merely the production of graphic symbols. Similarly, Nunan (2003) highlights that while writing is a physical representation of words and symbols, it is equally a product of the mind. Consequently, multiple cognitive and linguistic elements must be consciously coordinated to produce an effective piece of writing. Because English language teachers hold varying beliefs that shape their instructional decisions, this study explores how teachers’ perceptions and classroom practices are interrelated. Such an inquiry may also encourage teachers to critically reflect upon and improve their pedagogical practices in teaching writing skills.

In the context of Nepal, writing serves as a vital tool for higher education—both domestically and abroad—as well as for occupational and social success. Writing proficiency is particularly critical for secondary-level learners, as their academic grades are largely determined by their performance on written tests and assignments (Graham, 2006). Following the Secondary Education Examination (SEE), students transition into higher studies, where their academic trajectories often depend on their writing competence, particularly in securing admission through competitive entrance examinations. Furthermore, strong writing skills help students obtain full-time or part-time employment in schools and offices to support their livelihood during higher education. Navigating today’s competitive job market requires drafting effective job applications, while professional and academic growth demands proficiency in writing news reports and essays.

However, one of the most significant challenges in teaching writing at the secondary level in Nepal is the persistent dominance of examination-oriented, product-based writing instruction, which is often disconnected from students’ actual communicative needs and foundational English proficiency. Karki (2019), in his study of secondary-level English teachers in public and private schools in Sunsari, found that most teachers predominantly adopted the product approach to writing, emphasizing examination performance and the reproduction of model texts rather than engaging students in the processes of planning, drafting, revising and editing. The study identified several interconnected constraints, including large class sizes, pressure to complete the prescribed syllabus, learners’ low English proficiency, and inadequate instructional materials, teacher training and ICT facilities. Similarly, Sherma (2024) argues that writing instruction in Nepal tends to privilege rigid linguistic rules and examination requirements over writing for specific purposes, audiences and authentic communication. This examination-driven orientation becomes particularly problematic for learners with limited vocabulary, grammatical knowledge and sentence-construction skills, who often struggle to express their own ideas independently. Consequently, writing lessons may become exercises in memorising model compositions and reproducing expected answers rather than developing students’ creativity, critical thinking and communicative competence. The fundamental challenge, therefore, is not simply students’ weak English proficiency but the interaction between their linguistic limitations and a pedagogical and assessment culture that provides insufficient opportunities for meaningful, process-oriented writing.

Thus, developing robust writing skills is essential for secondary learners. Against this backdrop, this study explores teachers’ perceptions, pedagogical practices, and challenges they face in teaching writing.

Product Approach to Writing

A product approach to writing is a conventional methodology in which students are encouraged to mimic a model text that is typically supplied and analyzed at an early stage of instruction (Gabrielatos, 2002). Similarly, Badger and White (2000) assert that the product-based approach views writing as learning linguistic structures and improving proficiency through the imitation of teacher-provided texts. For instance, in a product-based writing classroom, students are given a standard sample text and asked to follow its structural pattern to construct a new piece of writing.

Process Approach to Writing

The process approach emerged in response to the limitations of the traditional product-based model of teaching writing. Flower (1989) notes that process writing developed as a reaction against conventional product-oriented instruction, allowing students to compose naturally, much like writing in their first language. Consistent with Flower’s perspective, this approach gives learners the opportunity to develop ideas organically in their second language rather than relying solely on rigid imitation. It guides students through recursive stages of composition, including pre-writing activities, drafting, revising, receiving and incorporating feedback, editing, and finally sharing their finished work.

Result and Discussion

Teachers’ Preparedness for Teaching Writing

Effective writing instruction requires thorough teacher preparation to ensure meaningful learning takes place (Cicek, 2013). Cicek notes that a daily lesson plan serves as a written account of what a teacher intends to accomplish during a specific lesson or class period. However, the teacher participants reported that they do not prepare written lesson plans due to several barriers: a lack of time and interest, low teacher motivation, perceived costs, and an absence of administrative support. Consequently, the findings reveal that none of the participants routinely prepared for daily lessons. Sima and Rajendra explained that time constraints prevented them from planning, as they balanced multiple responsibilities at school. Furthermore, all three teachers noted that preparing lesson plans is costly and unsupported by the school administration. Sima shared: “Sir, being an English teacher at this school, I have several other responsibilities. I have to conduct assemblies and run other extra-curricular and co-curricular activities. Because of that, I cannot prepare a lesson plan, though I want to prepare.” Similarly, Nitesh expressed regret: “I want to prepare a lesson plan. But sometimes we need money to buy materials. The head-teacher doesn’t help with such things, but also I prepare whenever I am free. I spend my money, sir.” The teachers also reported that lesson planning is not practiced school-wide, and those who attempt it face discouragement from colleagues without any institutional reward. Nitesh added: “Here in this school no teachers make lesson plans. If we make and do some extra labour we get nothing from anyone. Every teacher gets the same salary. Why should someone work for an extra hour, sir?”

Reflecting on these insights, I agree with Kiuhara et al. (2009), who argue that if teachers are to believe that planning fosters students’ writing development and delivers effective instruction, they must receive proper preparation for teaching writing. Comprehensive lesson planning should incorporate clear concepts or objectives, appropriate time blocks, procedural steps, and necessary instructional materials.

Teachers’ Practices in Teaching Writing 

The participant teachers employed distinct strategies to teach writing in their classrooms. Rajesh utilized controlled or parallel practice to teach film reviews; Rajendra applied a guided strategy for story writing; Nitesh engaged students in process-based writing; and Sima relied on the lecture or grammar-translation method for essay writing. Overall, Rajesh and Rajendra drew on product-based approaches, Naresh utilized a process-based approach, and Sima implemented the grammar-translation and lecture methods.

Controlled or parallel writing. The following is the classroom observation of Rajesh, who was teaching film review writing to a class of 30 grade-nine students. The classroom was bright and well-ventilated, with all four walls covered in chart papers from various subjects. Upon entering, Rajesh greeted his students and established a learning rapport by asking about their weekend activities. He then announced that he wanted to share a review of a movie he had watched over the weekend, asking two student volunteers to help paste a chart paper on the board.

In observing this practice, I noted that the teacher utilized a controlled or parallel strategy to teach film review writing. He presented a sample review that he had purposefully composed for the lesson, illustrating the principle that providing strong models is vital for guiding student imitation in the classroom.

Guided writing practice. I observed Rajendra’s grade-ten class, which comprised 13 girls and 9 boys. The classroom was spacious, with three students sharing a bench, though the back benches remained empty. A clock was mounted at the front just above the whiteboard. As Rajendra entered, the class stood up to offer traditional greetings. He then wrote the following prompt on the board: “Two goats → narrow bridge → come from two opposite directions→ both want to pass at the same time → both reach at the middle of the bridge → say “Let me go first!” → both get angry and fight → both fall into the river → moral.”

In this lesson, the teacher employed a guided strategy to teach short story writing. He began by discussing the fundamental elements of a short story before presenting a model sample.

Freewriting. Freewriting is another important strategy for developing student writing skills in schools, offering an innovative approach where students write spontaneously. Harmer (2007) asserts that freewriting provides powerful motivation, helping learners discover the right words to express their personal experiences.

An observation of Sima’s class revealed the following dynamic: she wrote “free writing” on the board and asked students, “What’s an essay? Have you written essays?” After the students responded affirmatively, she wrote the core structural elements—introduction, body, and conclusion—on the board. However, after observing the session, I noted that the teacher lacked a clear application of freewriting in a writing class. Instead of true freewriting, she wrote general essay headings on the whiteboard and assigned the students to write freely on the topic.

Process-based approach to writing. The process-based approach to writing involves distinct instructional stages: pre-writing, drafting, and rewriting or editing. These phases encompass conceptualizing topics, selecting relevant information and ideas, and guiding students through structural frameworks. Naresh attempted to implement a process approach while teaching essay writing.

I observed his class under challenging physical conditions: it was extremely cold outside, and the classroom was dark because all windows were closed tightly. A single ceiling bulb provided illumination, while the four walls were worn and covered in messy markings in chalk and marker. A whiteboard hung on the front wall, surmounted by a clock that displayed incorrect time. Twenty-six students were present. All students stood up to greet Naresh, who returned the greeting and instructed them to sit. He wrote “Essay writing” on the board, directed students to open their books to a specific page, and read aloud the essay titled “My First Visit to Zoo.” Following this reading, he instructed students to write an essay, writing the word “Brainstorming” on the board. Students provided different ideas and different stories of their visit to zoo. Teachers noted down the all different ideas of students. Then he made them select the ideas to include in the essay and also briefed about the language to be used in the essay. Students made the first rough draft. In the second day, students worked in pair to provide feedback to their peers. This way Naresh continued his lesson.

Reflecting on this classroom practice, I observed that Naresh made a sincere effort to implement a process-based approach. While he understood the conceptual framework, the lesson fell short of being fully effective for all learners. The students appeared puzzled because the expectations for each specific stage were unclear. During the observation, I realized that students required explicit instruction and guided practice particularly during the pre-writing brainstorming phase. Hedge (2001) notes that during this stage, students generate ideas and formulate writing plans. To achieve better learning outcomes, the teacher could have encouraged students to collaborate with peers during brainstorming, alongside providing clearer conceptual guidance on drafting and editing.

Conclusion

This study explored secondary English teachers’ perceptions and classroom practices regarding writing instruction in public schools in Nepal. While teachers recognize writing as an essential communicative skill and believe they implement effective, evidence-based process and product approaches, classroom realities reveal a significant disconnect between their beliefs and actual practices.

In practice, writing instruction remains largely unplanned and surface-level. Teachers rarely prepare daily lesson plans, provide sufficient model texts, foster peer collaboration, or offer constructive feedback—often ending lessons without students producing independent writing. This gap is compounded by systemic and pedagogical barriers, including time constraints, large class sizes, limited resources, diverse student backgrounds, and a lack of practical training in implementing writing strategies. Ultimately, the challenge does not lie in teachers’ conceptual understanding of writing instruction, but in their classroom execution. To bridge this gap between belief and practice, secondary English teachers require targeted professional development, institutional support for lesson planning, and practical training in scaffolding collaborative, process-oriented writing activities.

The author: Chandra Prakash Oli holds MPhil from a Nepali university. Mr. Oli serves as a Lecturer and Assistant Campus Chief at Yerawati Adarsha Multiple Campus in Dang, Nepal, where he also coordinates the M.Ed. program and the Research Management Cell (RMC).

References

Badger, R., & White, G. (2000). A process genre approach to teaching writing. ELT Journal, 54(2), 153–160. https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/54.2.153

Byrne, D. (1988). Teaching writing skills (New ed.). Longman.

Cicek, V. (2013). Effective use of lesson plans to enhance education in U.S. and Turkish kindergarten thru 12th grade public school system: A comparative study. International Journal of Teaching and Education, 1(2), 10–20.

Flower, L. (1989). Cognition, context, and theory building. College Composition and Communication, 40(3), 282–311. https://doi.org/10.2307/357775

Gabrielatos, C. (2002). EFL writing: Product and process. ERIC. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED476839

Graham, S. (2006). Strategy instruction and the teaching of writing: A meta-analysis. In C. A. MacArthur, S. Graham, & J. Fitzgerald (Eds.), Handbook of writing research (pp. 187–207). Guilford Press.

Hall, C. (1988). Managing the complexity of revising across languages. TESOL Quarterly, 24(1), 43–60. (Note: Please verify if you used a different 1988 work by Hall).

Harmer, J. (2007). The practice of English language teaching (4th ed.). Pearson Longman.

Hedge, T. (2001). Teaching and learning in the language classroom. Oxford University Press. (Note: The first edition was published in 2000; keep 2001 if citing the specific reprint you used).

Jacobs, H. L., Zinkgraf, S. A., Wormuth, D. R., Hartfiel, V. F., & Hughey, J. B. (1981). Testing ESL composition: A practical approach. Newbury House.

Karki, T. (2019). Writing instruction in secondary schools: Unraveling practices and challenges. Journal of NELTA Gandaki, 1, 108–118. https://doi.org/10.3126/jong.v1i0.24465

Kiuhara, S. A., Graham, S., & Hawken, L. S. (2009). Teaching writing to high school students: A national survey. Journal of Educational Psychology, 101(1), 136–160. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013097

Nunan, D. (2003). Practical English language teaching. McGraw-Hill.

Renukadevi, D. (2014). The role of listening in language acquisition: The challenges & strategies in teaching listening. International Journal of Education and Information Studies, 4(1), 59–63.

Sherma, A. B. (2024). Writing for specific audiences: A comparative study of teaching writing in Nepal and the U.S. ELE Praxis, 1(1), 24–35. https://doi.org/10.51474/elepraxis.v1i1.551

The Impact of Daily Post-Class Reflection on Students’ Learning and Performance in English

  Mr. Arjun Jung Rayamajhi

Abstract

This reflective paper explores how daily post-class reflection impacts students’ learning outcomes and performance in English, drawing upon insights from my own classroom teaching experience. To encourage students to identify their key takeaways from each class, challenges, and areas for growth, I implemented a brief reflection activity at the end of each lesson. Through systematic observation over time, I noted positive developments in students’ English writing skills, attentiveness, classroom participation, self-awareness, and overall engagement with reading and learning. This practice effectively supported students by bridging learning gaps and fostering greater personal accountability and a deeper understanding of the learning process. Furthermore, student reflections provided valuable formative feedback, enabling me to evaluate and refine my instructional strategies. Ultimately, this reflection suggests that regular post-class review enhances formative assessment, accelerates language skill development, and cultivates learner autonomy, highlighting the value of embedding post-class reflection into everyday pedagogy to promote meaningful learning.

 Keywords: Post–class reflection, student learning, academic performance, learner autonomy

Introduction

Teaching is not just a profession for me; it is a passion. I have always enjoyed teaching and learning activities since I started my teaching career. Over time, new and innovative pedagogical methods have been introduced and practised in classroom teaching. Post-class reflection (PCR) is one such teaching-learning practice that I have been implementing for the past three to four years.

Initially, I did not know much about post-class reflection, its writing patterns, or its potential benefits for students. I became familiar with PCR at Kathmandu University when I enrolled in a master’s degree in English Language Teaching (ELT). During my studies, I personally realised its relevance and significance for students’ learning. Since then, I have incorporated reflective writing into my teaching practice.

Post-class reflection is a structured writing activity in which students review and reflect on their learning experiences immediately after a lesson or class. It enables them to identify what they have learned, what they found difficult, how they participated in classroom activities, and what they need to improve in subsequent lessons. As Voorhees et al. (2022) explain, end-of-class reflection allows students to summarise key learning points, identify concepts they have understood, and recognise areas that require further clarification. Thus, PCR provides students with an opportunity to become more conscious of their learning processes and take greater ownership of their academic development.

Initially, I introduced PCR as a whole-class reflective activity, focusing on how the class began, what was taught, my contribution, what could have been done better, and the major takeaways from the lesson. After recognising its importance, I introduced this practice in Grades 11 and 12 science and management classes at a community school in Nawalpur, a city in western part of Nepal. In every class, students were required to write their reflections and submit them to the teacher. Sometimes, they were also encouraged to read their reflections aloud in class. I regularly checked their writing and provided feedback to identify missing information and areas for improvement.

As students continued writing reflections regularly, I noticed improvements in several areas, including handwriting, writing habits, and the ability to recall and memorise lesson content. These developments appeared to support their academic performance. More importantly, the practice helped students become increasingly aware of their learning processes and take greater responsibility for their academic development. Although this initially seemed like a simple classroom activity, I had not anticipated that it would bring such visible and meaningful changes to my students.

Over time, I observed several positive changes in students’ handwriting, writing skills, attention, learning habits, classroom participation, and overall academic performance. These classroom observations are also consistent with research findings. Radović et al. (2023), for example, reported positive relationships between prompted reflection and students’ academic performance. Their study further demonstrated that structured reflective writing could encourage deeper reflection and strengthen the connection between theoretical knowledge and practical learning experiences.

Another important aspect of this practice was that students’ reflections helped me understand their actual learning experiences and difficulties. Some students reported that they had understood the main concepts of the lesson but still needed additional support in particular areas. Others identified specific learning activities or skills that they found particularly helpful. These responses provided valuable insights into students’ individual learning needs and enabled me to make appropriate instructional adjustments in subsequent lessons. Such adjustments included providing additional explanations, organising further practice activities, encouraging peer support, and revisiting previously taught concepts. In this way, PCR became not only a reflective learning activity for students but also a valuable source of feedback for improving my own teaching practices.

Implementation of Post-class Reflection

The main purpose of introducing daily post-class reflection was to encourage students to think critically about their own learning. Rather than simply leaving the classroom after a lesson, I wanted them to pause and consider what they had learned, understood, found new or difficult, and needed to remember. These questions gradually encouraged students to examine their learning experiences and become more conscious of their progress.

One of the first noticeable changes was an improvement in students’ handwriting. Initially, many students were more concerned with completing their written work than with its presentation. Their handwriting was sometimes difficult to read, and they paid little attention to letter formation, spacing, and neatness. However, regular reflective writing gradually made them more careful. Their handwriting became cleaner, more organised, and easier to read. This experience showed me that consistent and meaningful writing practice can contribute to improving students’ handwriting without requiring separate handwriting lessons.

Another significant change was in students’ writing skills. Initially, many struggled to express their thoughts in English. Their reflections were often brief, repetitive, and grammatically weak. Although some knew what they wanted to communicate, they found it difficult to express their ideas in writing. Regular practice gradually increased their confidence in using vocabulary, constructing sentences, connecting ideas, and expressing personal opinions. They also became more conscious of their writing errors and attempted to avoid repeating them. Thus, PCR provided an additional opportunity for regular English writing practice alongside its reflective purpose.

I also noticed changes in students’ classroom attention and participation. Knowing that they would write a reflection at the end of each lesson encouraged them to listen more carefully and identify important points. They became more attentive to lesson content, classroom activities, and discussions. I felt that they were no longer simply attending classes but were making greater efforts to engage with what was being taught. As Guo (2022) suggests, reflection can help learners examine their learning experiences and develop greater awareness of their learning processes. Students’ written responses also provided insights into what they had understood, what remained unclear, and which classroom activities they found meaningful.

Another important outcome was the development of students’ self-awareness and responsibility for learning. Students gradually became more willing to acknowledge when they had not understood a particular concept or needed additional support. Their reflections helped me identify learning gaps and provide further explanations, practice activities, or revision where necessary. In this respect, PCR also functioned as a formative assessment strategy. Andrade and Valtcheva (2009) emphasise that self-assessment enables students to recognise their strengths and weaknesses and identify areas for improvement. Similarly, Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick (2006) highlight the role of formative feedback in developing students’ capacity to monitor and regulate their own learning.

I also observed improvements in students’ learning habits and academic performance. Although I cannot attribute these improvements solely to PCR, I believe that regular reflection contributed to students’ engagement with lesson content and revision of previously learned concepts. Recalling important ideas, vocabulary, examples, and lesson points helped them revisit their learning experiences. This observation is consistent with Radović et al. (2023), who reported positive relationships between prompted reflection and students’ academic performance.

Most importantly, PCR gradually became part of the classroom learning culture. Students began to recognise learning as a continuous process rather than an activity limited to classroom attendance or examination preparation. The practice also influenced my own teaching. By reading students’ reflections, I could identify which aspects of a lesson were clear, which required further explanation, and how students experienced particular teaching activities. Some responses revealed misunderstandings that I had not identified during the lesson. Consequently, PCR became a two-way reflective process: students reflected on their learning, while I used their responses to evaluate and improve my teaching.

Conclusion

Post-class reflection has become a crucial part of my teaching, helping students recall and memorize what they learned in class. What was taught in the class? What was your contribution? These questions help remind and recall what they learned in the classroom. These practices help improve their academic performance. It is also good for the teacher. I realize that what started as a small classroom practice has become a meaningful part of my teaching-learning process. The changes are not limited to handwriting or writing. I have seen students becoming more attentive, thoughtful, expressive, responsible, and conscious of their own learning. Their reflections have helped them connect classroom learning with their personal experiences and have helped me understand my students more closely. This experience has strengthened my belief that effective teaching does not always require complicated techniques. Sometimes, simple, consistent practice can make a significant difference. Five or ten minutes of meaningful reflection at the end of a class can encourage students to think, write, remember, evaluate, and improve. More importantly, it gives students a voice in their own learning. For me, daily post-class reflection is therefore not just a writing exercise. It is a habit-building strategy, a language-learning activity, a formative assessment tool, and a bridge between teaching and learning. The improvement I have witnessed in my students has encouraged me to continue this practice. I believe that when students regularly reflect on what they learned, how they learned, and what they still need to learn, they gradually become more independent and responsible learners. Ultimately, the greatest achievement of this practice is not simply that students write better or maintain neater handwriting. It is that they have started to think about their own learning. Moreover, when students begin to reflect on their learning, they also begin to take ownership of it. In my experience, that is one of the most valuable changes a teacher can hope to see in a classroom.

The author:  Arjun Jung Rayamajhi is a secondary-level English teacher serving in a community school in Nawalpur, Nepal. Mr Rayamajhi holds an M.Phil. in English Language Education from the School of Education, Kathmandu University. His areas of interest include Information and Communication Technology in education, Artificial Intelligence, teacher professional development, and pedagogical transformation.

References

Andrade, H., & Valtcheva, A. (2009). Promoting learning and achievement through self-assessment. Theory Into Practice, 48(1), 12–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/00405840802577544

Guo, L. (2022). How should reflection be supported in higher education? A meta-analysis of reflection interventions. Reflective Practice, 23(1), 118–146. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623943.2021.1995856

Nicol, D. J., & Macfarlane-Dick, D. (2006). Formative assessment and self-regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher Education, 31(2), 199–218. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075070600572090

Radović, S., Firssova, O., Hummel, H. G. K., & Vermeulen, M. (2023). Improving academic performance: Strengthening the relation between theory and practice through prompted reflection. Active Learning in Higher Education, 24(2), 111–122. https://doi.org/10.1177/14697874211014411

Voorhees, D. H., LeMay, L. E., Nagy, E. A., & Perez, A. E. (2022). Successes with metacognition: Empowering faculty and transforming student learning. New Directions for Community Colleges, 2022(199), 17–33. https://doi.org/10.1002/cc.20521

Assessing English language learners in remote teaching-learning

 

Puskar Chaudhary

This paper aims to explore the techniques and tools used for assessing the English language learners in remote teaching-learning and to discuss the challenges and obstacles faced by the teachers while assessing the learners. Based on a collective study design, this paper presents a study on the assessment practices in remote teaching-learning. Data were collected from three English language teachers of basic education level using online interviews. The results showed that many English language teachers transitioned to remote teaching learning because of the  COVID -19 pandemic and whether it is a face to face class or remote teaching-learning, assessment is an integral part of the teaching-learning to check the understanding of the subject matter and to evaluate whether the educational goals and standards of the lessons are being met. The assessments were taken more or less similar to the face-to-face mode via written or oral practices with the help of technologies and while assessing the learners, the teachers faced the Internet connection issues, investment of ample time for designing and organizing the assessment with the help of technologies. The teachers gained less support from the parents and students for conducting the effective assessment.

Keywords: Assessment, remote teaching-learning, techniques and tools, educational goals, integral

 Introduction

This study assessed the English language learners based on their mode of acquiring learning that is either through face-to-face or remote teaching-learning.  Remote Teaching -Learning (RTL) offers teaching learning beyond the physical classrooms. It is the learning process where the teachers are separated from the learners in time and distance. According to Graham (2019), RTL is the practice of teaching a language interactively via videoconferencing. He further describes that it differs from telecollaboration which mainly focuses on enabling language teaching and learning to take place rather than on intercultural collaboration. In remote language teaching, both students and teachers interact through two-way communication technologies. Similarly, in Belz and Thorne’s (2006) view, RLT supports learners’ interaction with the teachers and peers, encourages them to have more dialogue, debate, and intercultural exchange. Remote teaching is also referred to as live online language teaching to refer to synchronous (i.e. in real-time) computer-mediated communication for language teaching (Swertz et al., 2007). In RLT, teachers focus on both pedagogy and technology to provide huge opportunities for effective learning and collaboration beyond the physical classroom. They involve approaches and techniques that are more connected with the technologies. Whereas, Whyte and Gijsen (2016) argue that there is an ample burden for the teachers to conduct the classes remotely than for regular face-to-face classes. Teachers are committed to helping the learners with these different ways of working and teaching them in the most effective way possible. Teachers require and prepare designed and written materials to take advantage of the teaching and learning context and delivery method (i.e. video conferencing). Therefore, remote teaching is an innovative way of bridging cultural and geographical distances and enables the teaching and learning of languages to students who would otherwise not have the opportunity.

At present, most English language teachers had to opt for remote learning because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Many teachers had transition to remote learning with no advance notice or preparation earlier this year. Some are planning for remote learning in the fall when they return to school. It is important to remember that remote learning refers to a class that intends to meet face-to-face. The teachers have been practising to replicate remote learning as far as possible into the real face-to-face classes. It is not just enough with the engagement of teaching-learning activities. The learners should be assessed to check the understanding of the subject matter and to evaluate whether the educational goals and standards of the lessons are being met. The learners must be able to think critically, analyze, and make inferences. Hence, assessing them is the most challenging factor in RTL. Nitko and Broookhart (2013) opine that organizing assessment helps the teachers to collect the information about teaching-learning and well as the students’ performance to make the certain decision teaching. Assessment in English language teaching has been defined as “involving professional judgment based upon an image formed by the collection of information about student performance” (Stanley, 2019, p. 8). Similarly, Wolf (2020) states that assessments are a critical means of identifying learners and monitoring their achievements. Assessments also play a fundamental role in teaching and learning, since it helps to gather the important information about students’ needs, which helps teachers provide appropriate support and interpret their academic performance accurately. Assessment is one of the important aspects which is being treated as a teaching-learning process as well (Stiggins, 1991). Assessing learners is a very important and essential part of a teacher’s teaching (Nitko, 1996). It is an integrated process for determining the nature and extent of student’s learning and achievement (Linn & Gronland, 2005).

According to Stanley (2019), there are two types of assessment: formative and summative. Assessment can be formative when it is to improve learning and assessment is summative when it is for monitoring and certificating performance or achievement. During the year, formal and informal instances of the formative assessment provide information to Remote Teachers (RTs) and Classroom Teachers (CTs) about student learning so adjustments can be made to teaching.

Assessment is an important aspect of teaching-learning. It offers the teachers to go up to the next class and to figure out whether the students are included. It also helps to get the results of the teaching-learning activities. On the other hand, it makes the teachers ready to take a proficiency test and provide the students the grades.

Research Questions

This study sought to answer the following research questions:

  • How do English Language teachers assess students in remote teaching-learning?
  • What challenges do English language teachers face while assessing students in remote teaching-learning?
Methodology

This is a qualitative study that used a collective case study design to explore the questions. According to Stake (1995), a case study is the study of the particularity and complexity of a single case, coming to understand its activity within important circumstances. It helps to collect the information in detail and understand the problem in-depth with its real-life context. The case study design is an important tool for exploring and describing a phenomenon in context while refining theory and identifying areas for more exploration (Yin, 2018). Data were collected from three English Language Teachers of Basic Education Level who were assessing students by using different techniques and tools and while assessing them in remote teaching-learning in one of the schools of Kathmandu Valley. The teachers were a diverse group in terms of their ethnicity, gender, and grade level experiences. I collected data, which included notes of observation and interaction during online classes and interview with synchronous tools like Zoom Cloud Meeting (5 times in total); written reflections for each teacher related to assigned articles, email and Facebook messages correspondence with pupils, and transcriptions of semi-formal small group interviews. I conducted two rounds of interviews individually with teachers and three rounds of interviews in a group. Each interview lasted approximately 40 minutes. I followed them twice a week. The data occurred in two phases. First, I divided the data sets for coding purposes. In this initial phase, I examined individual cases, techniques, and the tools used for assessing the students in remote teaching-learning. Comparing the responses, I coded and analyzed them into the four themes: Observations, Discussion, Feedback, and Self-assessment.

Next, I collectively asked the participants what challenges they were facing while assessing the students in the remote teaching-learning. The responses were kept under different themes in which the individual cases were combined and compared to create a collective case study. After collecting data by qualitative technique, the data were analyzed and interpreted qualitatively. The following sections represent the results obtained from data analysis.

Results and discussion

This study aimed to explore the techniques and tools adopted by English Language teachers for assessing students in remote teaching-learning and to find out the challenges English language teachers face while assessing students in remote teaching-learning. Therefore, the results gained via the interview data were put into two sub-sections: Assessment for learning techniques and Challenges.

Techniques and tools for assessing in remote teaching-learning

This section presents the data derived by observing the English Language Teaching (ELT) class to answer the first research question, exploring the techniques and tools adopted by English Language teachers for assessing students in remote teaching-learning.

Observations

Informal teacher observations: In remote teaching-learning, the teachers were found observing different things in their classes. They observed how well the students managed to focus when doing the tasks. Furthermore, how much time do the students need to do certain tasks? And whether the students were willing to volunteer or respond when called on. The teachers in the interview also added that they observed the students if they were prepared for the task or provide help.

Student-led observations: Teachers assessing English language learners using remote methods checked the students’ autonomy and responsibility in their learning. They were asked to follow the netiquettes as it was remote teaching. They were given responsibilities where they took attendance and gave their opinions on what was happening in the class. Furthermore, they were asked to provide the class report either to the class teacher or the subject teacher.

Discussions

Teacher participants in the interview shared that they assessed the students in remote teaching-learning by giving different learning situations. They assessed through the discussions in the live classes. Discussions were done on the usages of techniques and digital tools by the teachers, about the language usage L1 or L2. In addition to this, the discussion where the students did share in a peer, small group, or the whole class was also assessed. Lastly, the assessment was made when the students were provided with options during controlled practice.

Feedback

Students in remote teaching-learning were assessed based on the feedback given by them. Following things were taken into considerations when assessing the feedback given by them. Students were asked to give feedback when their peers participated or did any work. They would give feedback on their friends’ thinking process, presentation, content, gestures, etc. They were asked to provide positive and critical feedback which could motivate their friends to perform better and which would help to create a healthy atmosphere.

Self-assessment

Self-assessment is another technique used by the teachers to assess English language students in remote teaching. They explained that they used active recall questions to check the students’ progress. The students were asked to do the self-assessments by preparing PowerPoint presentations, using digital tools to do their project works, encouraging them to write journals, blogs, etc. They were also asked to take objective tests with the help of google forms and other online platforms. Furthermore, they were asked to appear for the written subjective tests. Recording the voice or video on any academic topic was promoted which they had to send to the teachers. Finally, some teachers asked them to attend the class on time.

Challenges in assessing students in remote teaching-learning

This section presents the data derived by observing the ELT class to answer the second research question, exploring the challenges and the obstacles faced by the teachers assessing the learners in remote teaching-learning.

Students with the internet issues

The teachers have found that most of the learners had the Internet with low bandwidth. There were also the chances of power cuts and disconnection while taking the synchronous class. The teachers responded that because of low connectivity they had to turn off their camera and be connected with mobile data.

Students with not enough support

The teachers revealed that the students were getting less support from their parents and seniors regarding the use of laptops and digital tools while taking the classes. The children were also less supervised by the parents while taking the classes. There were more chances of getting distracted and being engaged in playing online games.

Widening gaps between students’ proficiency

The teachers explained that there was an individual difference in remote teaching-learning. All the students did not have the same digital literacy and level of competency. The children faced problems while submitting the assignments, communicating with the teachers, and handling the tools.

Difficulty in supporting individuals

It was very time-consuming for the teachers to prepare the lessons and spending more on screen. The teachers had to spend more time preparing PowerPoint presentations and giving feedback to the students because of the technical issues the teachers were unable to give the class and communicate with the learners properly.

Conclusion

The present study investigated the assessment techniques and tools used by the English language teachers for assessing the learning in the remote teaching-learning and the challenges and obstacles faced by the teachers while assessing them in the remote teaching-learning. Results of the study showed that assessment was an integral part of teaching-learning to check the understanding of the subject matter and to evaluate whether the learning goals were achieved or not. The teachers did the planning, implementing, and organizing of the lesson by using digital and printed materials to assess the learners. The teachers engaged the learners in the discussion in the remote learning, observation of the lesson, engaging them in the feedback and self-assessment. While following those techniques, the teachers also encountered challenges related to the technologies and with the students’ well-being.

About the author

Mr. Puskar Chaudhary is an MPhil practitioner at Kathmandu University. He works as a full-time faculty and coordinates with the Digital Literacies Programme at Triyog High School, Tokha, Kathmandu. He is also a life member of Nepal English Language Teachers’ Association (NELTA) and International Association of Teachers of English as a Foreign Language (IATEFL). His current interests include digital pedagogy, digital literacies programme, and teachers’ networking, and professional development.

References

Nitko, A. J. & Brookhart, S. (2013). Educational assessment of students. Pearson.

Belz, J. A. & Thorne, S. L. (2006). Internet-mediated intercultural foreign language education. Thomson Heinle.

Coniam, D. (Ed.). (2014). English language education and assessment: Recent development in Hong Kong and the Chinese mainland. Singapur: Springer-Verlag.

Hill, C. & Parry, K. (2014). From testing to assessment: English an international language (Applied linguistics and language study). Routledge.

Linn, R. L. & Gronland, N.E. (2005). Measurement and assessment in teaching. Pearson Education.

Rahman, M., Babu, R., & Ashrafuzzaman, M. (2011). Assessment and feedback practices in the English language classroom. Journal of NELTA, 16(1-2), 97-106. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.3126/nelta.v16i1-2.6133

Rivera, C. (2006). State assessment policy and practice for English language learners: A national perspective. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers Inc.

Shrestha, P. (2014). Alternative assessment approaches in primary English language classrooms. Journal of NELTA, 18(1-2), 148-163. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.3126/nelta.v18i1-2.10337

Stanley, G. (Ed). (2019). Innovation in education remote teaching. British Council.

Stiggins, R. J. (1991). Relevant classroom assessment training for teachers. educational measurement: Issues and Practice, 10(1), 7-12.

Swertz, C., Motteram, G., Philp, H. & Gonul, S. (2007). Language learning with certified live online language teachers: Teacher Manual. Retrieved from https://www.scribd.com/document/198458088/LANCELOT-Teacher- Manual

Unruh, S. & McKellar, N. A. (2017). Assessment and intervention for English language learners: Translating research into practice. Springer International Publishing.

Whyte, S. & Gijsen, L. (2016) ‘Telecollaboration in secondary EFL: A blended teacher education course. In S. Jager, M. Kurek,  and B. O’Rourke,  (eds.), New directions in telecollaborative research and practice: selected papers from the second conference on telecollaboration in higher education (pp. 163-170). Research-publishing.net.https://doi.org/10.14705/rpnet.2016. telecollab2016.503

Wolf, M. K. (2020). Assessing English language proficiency in US K-12 Schools. Routledge.

Can be cited as:

Chaudhary, P. (2021, May). Assessing English language learners in remote teaching-learning [Blog article].  ELT CHOUTARI. Available at: https://eltchoutari.com/2021/04/assessing-english-language-learners-in-remote-teaching-learning/

What makes English language teaching effective?

Prakash Bhattarai

Abstract

Due to the widespread use of English language throughout the globe, teaching and learning English language has got really surprising importance. This has raised a number of questions related to effective English language teaching. In this scenario, with the help of the author’s own experience in teaching English language for more than a decade, this article elaborates different factors that are responsible for effective English language teaching. Teachers, methods and techniques, teaching materials, and learners themselves are such factors that are responsible for effective English language teaching.

Introduction

English has been developed as a global language due to globalization in recent decades. It is the language of international trade, tourism, education, and diplomacy. Similarly, it has been developed as an international lingua franca. It is being a must to learn and speak English language to be one of the members of this globalized world.  Due to the growing spread and need for the English language throughout the world, there is an amazing trend in learning English language. This amazing trend in learning English language for different purposes has resulted in the teaching of English language widely. Many institutions and language schools are active to teach the English language throughout the world.

In order to make learners achieve the goal of learning English language, the learners should be taught English language effectively. No doubt, effective English language teaching makes effective learning but there arise genuine questions i.e., what is effective English language teaching and what makes it effective? Defining effective teaching is difficult since it is a complex and multidimensional process that means different things to different people (Bell, 2005). Though it’s difficult to define, we can simply define ‘effective’ as being successful in producing a desired or intended outcome. Effective teaching involves the ability to provide instruction that helps the students to develop different knowledge, skills, and understandings intended by curriculum objectives and students learn irrespective of their characteristics (Acheson & Gall 2003, as cited in Uygun, 2013).

Effective English language teaching makes learners learn English language with ease. It means to say that learners become able to communicate in English language effectively within a short period of time. Students demonstrate an understanding of meanings rather than just simply memorizing facts in an effective English language teaching classroom (Ghimire, 2019).

Factors making English language teaching effective

After defining effective teaching in general and effective English language teaching in particular, there is still an unanswered question i.e., what makes teaching effective? There are a number of factors that make English language teaching effectively. In order to make it effective, there is a direct and/or indirect hand of all the stakeholders involved in English language teaching. Teachers, students, parents, institutions, and administrators are the stakeholders to name a few.

My experience of being an English language learner for ages and English language teacher for a decade reveals that different factors play a pivotal role in effective English language teaching. As per my experience, a teacher’s personality, knowledge (content and pedagogical), and learners’ activation, motivation, and readiness are prerequisites for effective teaching. Moreover, teacher’s knowledge of technology and being updated with the recent trends in English language teaching are must for effective teaching in this era. In this section, I have explained four factors i.e. teacher, methods and techniques, teaching materials, and learners.

Teacher

There is a pivotal role of teachers for effective English language teaching. For effective English language teaching, English language teacher/instructor needs to be effective. An effective teacher is the one who possesses different components like content knowledge, general pedagogical knowledge, curriculum knowledge, pedagogical content knowledge, knowledge of learners and their characteristics, knowledge of educational ends, purposes, and values, and knowledge of educational contexts (Clark & Walsh, 2002 as cited in Uygun, 2013). This shows teachers should have content knowledge, pedagogical knowledge, and socio-affective skills. To put it another way, an effective teacher is the one who has good command over the subject matter, good knowledge of the methods and techniques for the effective delivery, and good rapport with the students. Similarly, an effective and dynamic teacher should be enthusiastic, creative, tolerant, patient, kind, sensible, open-minded, optimistic, and flexible, and have a good sense of humour, positive attitudes toward new ideas, and some other personal characteristics (Ghimire, 2019).

Having content and pedagogical knowledge and some other personal characteristics as mentioned above is not sufficient for effective teaching in this era. Since this is the era of science and technology, it has a great deal of impact on teaching as in other sectors. Information and communication technology (ICT) has impacted each and every aspect of human life from which education sector in general and teaching-learning activities, in particular, cannot be an exception. Defining ICT Hafifah (2019, p. 21) states, “…ICT is defined as the activities of using technologies, such as; computer, internet, and other telecommunications media… to communicate, create and disseminate, store and manage information” and ICT in education means teaching and learning by the use of different ICT devices. Information and communication technologies (ICTs) are being used in education to support students to learn more effectively by providing teachers with access to a wide range of new pedagogy (Dhital, 2018). Due to the use of ICTs in education, it has changed a number of factors like pedagogy, student-teacher relationship, the concept of literacy, and students’ learning achievement. Students and teachers who were only exposed to the traditional way of teaching-learning activities have shifted their way of teaching and learning. It helps students compete in this global market. ICT in education enhances learning, provides students with a new set of skills, facilitates and improves the training of teachers, and minimizes costs associated with the delivery of traditional instruction (UNESCO, 2014). Therefore, teachers should have the technological knowledge for effective language teaching. He/ She should be ICT literate along with the ability to use and incorporate ICT in language teaching. The teacher needs to be updated with the technological knowledge since it is always in a state of flux more so than content and pedagogical knowledge (Harris, Mishra & Koehler, 2009). In a nutshell, the teacher of this era should be ICT literate first and updated with the changing trends in ICT so that effective language teaching can take place.

Similarly, English language teachers should have a good command of English language. It does not mean that teachers should be native speakers of English. Even a non-native speaker who is good at English can be an effective English language teacher. The teacher should know the students (level, background, interest, need) and have a good rapport with them. The knowledge and command of the target language, ability to organize and clarify the contents, arouse and sustain interest and motivation among students, and fairness and availability to students are the desirable features of an effective second language teacher (Uygun, 2013). Moreover, an effective English language teacher should be clear and enthusiastic in teaching, provide learners with phonological, grammatical, lexical, pragmatic, and sociocultural knowledge.

Methods and techniques

Teaching methods and techniques used in language classrooms play a vital role in effective English language teaching. A method is often regarded as the heart of teaching-learning activities. It is the overall plan for the orderly presentation of language material. Different methods can be used for effective teaching. Since the methods which work best in one context may not be effective in the next context, a teacher should use methods that are context and culture-sensitive. It means the teacher should use the methods and techniques being based on the context where he/she is teaching. In this line, Kumaravadivelu (2001) writes; “Language pedagogy to be relevant must be sensitive to a particular group of teachers teaching a particular group of learners pursuing a particular set of goals within a particular institutional context embedded in a particular sociocultural milieu (p. 538)”. For this, teachers should use self-generated methods which best fit their context. Action research and reflective practice help teachers generate such methods. Teachers need to be autonomous, dynamic, reflective, and intuitive. In a nutshell, teachers should practise what they theorize and theorize what they practice (Kumaravadivelu, 2001).

Teaching materials

For effective English language teaching, the teaching materials teachers use in language classrooms also play a vital role. Since the materials used in English language classroom make teaching lively and effective, teachers rely on different materials to support their teaching and their students’ learning. The teaching material, let it be commercially produced or self-made should address the needs, levels, and interests of the students. The materials used in language classrooms should be content and context-sensitive. They should stimulate interaction and be generative in terms of language, encourage learners to develop learning skills and strategies, allow for a focus on form as well as function, offer opportunities for integrated language use, be authentic, link to each other to develop a progression of skills, understandings, and language items, be attractive and have appropriate instructions and be flexible (Howard & Major, 2004).

Learners

Like other factors, a learner is also one of the factors that make teaching effective. Learners should be active and creative to carry out the activities conducted both in and outside the classroom. An active and creative learner is related to a successful learner who sets and accomplishes his  or her own goals (Karen, 2001). According to Zamani and Ahangari (2016), “Good teaching is clearly important to raising student achievement, if teacher is not aware of the learner’s expectation and needs related to the course, it will have negative outcomes regarding the students’ performance” (p. 70). So, for effective teaching, a teacher should make the students active and creative. Making learners active and creative means engaging them with materials to work collaboratively with their friends making themselves responsible in the classroom activities. A teacher should provide such tasks which promote learner autonomy on one hand and collaborative learning on the other.

Conclusion

Being based on the above ideas, it can be concluded that there is not a single factor that makes English language teaching effective. The first and foremost requirement for effective English language teaching is an effective teacher. Teachers should possess content, pedagogical and technological knowledge, and socio-affective skills to make teaching effective. Secondly, the materials and methods the teacher uses in the language classroom should be context and culture-sensitive because the prescribed methods and materials developed by other experts may not work properly in all the contexts. For this, the teacher should develop their methods and materials that best fit their contexts with the help of action research and reflective practice. Finally, the learners should be active and creative for effective teaching and learning. For this, a teacher should use the tasks which foster learner autonomy and collaborative learning.

About the author

Prakash Bhattarai is pursuing his M.Phil. in English Education at the Graduate School of Education, Tribhuvan University. He has a decade-plus experience in teaching English language from primary to university level. Currently, he has been teaching at Kirtipur Secondary School, Kathmandu. To his credit, he has published a few academic articles in national and international journals. His professional interest includes ELT, Language planning and policy and English and multilingualism.

References

Bell, T. R. (2005). Behaviors and attitudes of effective foreign language teachers: Results of a questionnaire study. Foreign Language Annals, 38 (2), 259-270.

Dhital, H. (2018). Opportunities and challenges to use ICT in government school education of Nepal. International Journal of Innovative Research in Computer and Communication Engineering, 6(4), 3215-3220. doi:10.15680/IJIRCCE.2018.0604004

Ghimire, N. B. (2019). Five facets for effective English language teaching. Journal of NELTA Gandaki (JoNG), II, 65-73.

Hafifah, G.N. (2019). Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in English Language Teaching. Proceedings of MELTC (Muhammadiyah English Language Teaching Conference). 21-38. Muhammadiyah Surabaya:  Department of English Education, The University of Muhammadiyah Surabaya.

Harris, J. B., Mishra, P., & Koehler, M. (2009). Teachers’ technological pedagogical content knowledge and learning activity types: Curriculum-based technology integration reframed.  Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 41(3), 393-416.

Haword, J. & Major, J. (2004). Guidelines for Designing Effective English Language Teaching Materials. Retrieved from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237476568

Karen, S. (2001). First-year experiences series: Being a more effective learner. University of Sidney Learning Centre Publishing, Australia. Retrieved from: http://sydney.edu.au/stuserv/ documents/learning centre/EffectiveLearner.pdf

Kumaravadivelu, B. (2001). Toward a Post method Pedagogy. TESOL Quarterly, 35(4), 537-560.

UNESCO. (2014). Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in Education in Asia. Canada: UNESCO Institute of Statistics.

Uygun, S. (2013).How to become an effective English language teacher. Journal of Educational and Social Research, 3 (7) 306-311. doi:10.5901/jesr.2013.v3n7p306

Zamani, R. & Ahangari, S. (2016). Characteristics of an effective English language teacher (EELT) as perceived by learners of English. International Journal of Foreign Language Teaching & Research, 4 (14), 69-88.

Can be cited as:

Bhattarai, P. [2021, May]. What makes English language teaching effective? ELT CHOUTARI. Available at: https://eltchoutari.com/2021/04/what-makes-english-language-teaching-effective/

Enhancing patriotism through the local contents in ELT materials

Bhan Singh Dhami

Abstract

This article attempts to explore how the local contents in ELT materials can be utilized to enhance patriotism among English language learners in Nepal. The purpose of this study was to explore how the local contents in ELT materials support to enhance patriotism. By employing a phenomenological design of qualitative research with purposive sampling, the three graduate level English language learners were interviewed to collect the information for this research. Collecting audio-recorded interviews, the information was coded, analyzed, and interpreted thematically linking the information with relevant theories and previous studies. The results of this study indicate that the local contents and the texts of Nepali English writers’ in ELT materials and English courses can contribute to enhance patriotism among Nepali English language learners. This study also signals that all the stakeholders of Nepal’s ELT such as curriculum planners, course designers, and textbook writers should maximise the contents from Nepali contexts and culture in ELT course in Nepal.

Keywords: Patriotism, Local contents, Nepal-based contents, and Nepali English learners

Introduction

In this rapidly materialized era, education system of the country can play a major role to strengthen patriotic feelings in its citizens. In the context of Nepal, the local contents in ELT can contribute to orient students towards working for the welfare of their nation. Recently, the government of Nepal has released the actual map including the Nepali territories Kalapani, Lipulekh, and Limpiyadhura that lie in the east of the Mahakali River. This new map is included in our recently published school-level English textbooks which is highly appreciable. Similar initiatives and the contents from Nepali contexts and culture can contribute to enhancing patriotism among students in ELT classroom.

ELT in Nepal should go beyond the teaching of how to listen, speak, read, and write in English. ELT should include how to reform society, preserve our own culture, and enhance patriotism. Nussbaum (2013, p. 3) focused on “an education that cultivates the ability to see full and equal humanity in another person, perhaps one of humanity’s most difficult and fragile achievements.” ELT should primarily promote Nepal-based knowledge and culture. Giri (2015) asserts that English has become an indispensable part of life for the Nepali people in recent years. As English is introduced more and more early and widely, the contents in ELT materials should be carefully selected and graded to promote Nepali cultures and languages.

As far as my knowledge is concerned, there is scarcity of studies conducted in this area connecting patriotism with ELT in the context of Nepal. Therefore, perceiving this gap in the literature, I conducted this research so that it could help the major stakeholders especially English curriculum planners, English syllabus designers, and English textbook writers of Nepal to design curriculum and syllabuses to address this issue in the future.

Purpose of the study

The purpose of this study is to explore how the local contents in ELT can be utilized to strengthen patriotism in English language learners. This study specifically aims to explore the perceptions of Nepali English language learners on ELT in the light of patriotism.

Research question

This study aims to answer the following question:

  1. What are the perceptions of Nepali English language learners on ELT and patriotism?
Theoretical framework

Taking constructivism as a philosophical standpoint for this study, I take Vygotsky’s socio-cultural theory as a main theoretical base and ‘patriotism’ (Bar-Tal & Staub, 1997) as supportive theory.

Vygotsky advocates for socially constructed knowledge that can be obtained in society. In this sense, learning is considered a social process. Therefore, social phenomena and events have a significant role in learning a native or a foreign language. Learners live in their own societies; they have the feeling of intimacy with one another and they have deep love and respect for their society and geography. As Vygotsky considers learning as a social activity and the knowledge is socially constructed through interaction among the learners in social settings. Therefore, Vygotsky’s theory is widely popular in the sector of educational research which seems to be very useful in socially situated investigations of educational development and transformation (Marginson & Dang 2017). Furthermore, education should bring reformation in the mindset of learners to unite the nation in this rapidly globalized educational world.

According to Karsten (1908, p. 61), “For patriotism is not only a legitimate instinct of every healthy human being; it is the sacred duty of every citizen.” Kodelja (2019) highlighted that education and patriotism are closely connected to the learners. Therefore, patriotism can be taken as an indispensable part of the citizens’ life and this feeling is important and should be spread among the learners.

Methods

I conducted this research by using the phenomenological design of qualitative research. I collected the data required for this study using the unstructured interview technique from the Master’s level English language learners from Kailali district ranging from 25 to 30 years age. They were selected using the purposive sampling technique. They are mentioned as participant A, participant B, and participant C in this research. They were informed before, after, and during the research process about the aim of the research. Using two-step procedures, firstly, the information was collected, and secondly, it was analyzed by making different themes.

Tools

The information collection instrument consisted of background interviews and open-ended oral questions which were answered orally. The background interview covered the questions about their name, experiences, and present level of study. Mainly open-ended interviews were conducted by including research questions relevant to this study. The participants were asked to express their ideas and views on enhancing patriotism through ELT. Their views were audio recorded and transcribed.

Results and discussions

The results of the qualitative analysis are reported in three main themes: a) Patriotism as a backbone of Nepali ELT and learning, b) Patriotism as a lifeline of Nepali English language learners, and c) Patriotism as a guideline of Nepali ELT and learning.

Patriotism as a backbone of Nepali ELT and learning

When the researcher asked the question related to the connection of ELT and patriotism, participant A stated, “English is one of the foreign languages for Nepal. It is a language . . . for communication with foreigners. I hope we don’t forget our originality. For that the connection of patriotism with English language is essential.” Therefore, Nepal-based contents should be highly valued and included in both school-level and higher-level ELT materials. By including such contents in the materials, ELT classes can contribute to enhance love towards nation and its culture to the students. Saud (2020) stresses that the inclusion of local writings in academic courses will help to protect Nepali diverse cultures and the Nepali English literature will gain a new height. In fact, through the translation in English, we can showcase our culture and diversity globally.

Likewise, participant B expressed “In my view, without patriotism, the use of foreign language becomes meaningless. I don’t want to learn English to make my country a foreign land for me.” As participant B expresses ELT materials must include the local texts and foster the feelings of belongingness to the texts in the classroom. Therefore, English materials should prioritize patriotism in its contents, which can contribute to a dignified life of students in modern society.

Similarly, the participant C clearly stated “Where I was born and . . . where I stand determines patriotism. It is a backbone of English language teaching and learning and English should be taught and learned in this way. This is my understanding.” From the view of participant C, it is clear that patriotism should be the backbone of ELT materials and teaching- learning. Therefore, English can also be used as a tool to make Nepal known to the world. Saud (2020) states that ELT should be culturally sensitive and socially responsive valuing multicultural contexts. Eventually, patriotic contents help to strengthen any sort of solidarity for the welfare of the country and its people.

Patriotism as a lifeline of Nepali English language learners

Many Nepali learners are interested in English language learning due to its dominance in the whole world. However, many learners are leaving the country after learning English. Through the inclusion of patriotic contents, ELT materials can help to strengthen the students’ love towards the nation.

When the researcher asked another question regarding Nepal-based contents in English textbooks, participant A replied “In my opinion, the texts in English textbooks that we study are written by foreign writers. We should promote English texts written by Nepali writers. I think patriotism should be the lifeline for us.” Participant A reveals the status and representation of texts in our ELT materials and textbooks. In response to a similar question, the participant B opined:

In some English textbooks, I find some contents related to Nepal which we count on fingers. However, I think these are good signs of hope. Some of the Nepali English textbook writers prioritize Nepal-based content in English which is appreciable. I think so.  

Participant B acknowledges the inclusion of local texts in ELT materials and is hopeful to increase in future. It certainly signals a ray of hope, but the proportion of the local texts, discourse and culture should increase in ELT materials. Saud (2020) states that a language reflects culture. However, different cultures can also be reflected in one language. Likewise, participant C expressed “The amount of local contents is very minimal. English writers of Nepal . . . attention, please. Without knowing Nepal, how do we promote patriotism?” Considering the opinion of participant C, patriotism can be promoted if the learners know Nepal and its cultures, and students get to know more about their country and culture, if they are exposed to more reading materials with local contents and cultures.

Furthermore, the participant A (being energetic) replied “If some lessons related to Nepal are included in the textbooks, it really helps to enhance patriotism in the learners. It’s essential.” From the view of this participant, it can be inferred that the lessons related to Nepal play a great role to enhance the patriotic feeling in Nepali learners of English. Similar is the opinion of the participant B, who stressed “We must learn Nepali contents and culture in English language classroom and live in Nepal being Nepali not only in the heart but also in mind.”

Likewise, the participant C replied, “If patriotic, cultural and social contents are included in the English textbook, learners become curious and show interest in English language learning.” The view of participant C also indicates the necessity of Nepali contents in English textbooks which helps to enhance not only patriotism but also facilitate learning English with ease. When the learners find the texts and contents from their local culture, it is easy for them to comprehend, as a result, their learning gets better.

Patriotism as a guideline of Nepali ELT and learning    

Generally, common people believe that English is learned to go to a foreign country and earn money. It may be true to some extent, but it can also be learned to spread our history, culture, art, and knowledge in the different parts of the world.

In response to one of the researcher questions, the participant A says:

Let me talk about higher education. In English literature, many stories, poems, dramas, and novels written by foreigners are included in the course, but the texts created or written by Nepali writers are neglected . . . the textbook writers should include the creation of Nepali writers that represent patriotism. It can give Nepali flavor in English language teaching and learning.   

We can take the gist from participant A’s view that Nepali texts should be included in English materials, which is the need of time. Therefore, the texts of Nepali writers’ should be given priority in English textbooks. Saud (2020) urges the material developers to value local culture and include more and more local contents and texts in the materials in future. In response to a similar question, participant B expressed “In my opinion, English should be used to strengthen our country. English language should be utilized to strengthen our relations with us and others. I think . . . patriotism is a guideline for English language teaching and learning in Nepal.” The intention of participant B is that English can strengthen our internal and international relations. For that, patriotism can be taken as a guideline to ELT and learning of Nepal. In this sense, English can strengthen our country.

Bhandari (2016) argues that teaching English in multilingual and multicultural contexts in Nepal can be considered as one of the major challenges in ELT. Teachers can play a significant role to minimise it as Giri (2020) advocates that English teachers can play an important role minimize the hegemonic influence of native speakers. The hegemonic mindset can also be changed if Nepali contents get space in the ELT of Nepal.

Answering a similar question, participant C stated “ELT in Nepal should be focused on Nepali contents and contexts. At least fifty percent contents must be related to Nepal and should be included in English courses.” In participant C’s opinion, it can be inferred that Nepali contents should be kept at the centre of the ELT and learning of Nepal. Furthermore, Giri (2020) clearly mentions an example of whether the lesson is about ‘pollution’, the materials used should be the ones that are written about their own cities. Therefore, Nepal-based content should be included in the ELT of Nepal to enhance patriotism among the learners.

In this post-method era of language teaching and learning, socio-cultural contents get focused to enhance patriotism through the ELT of Nepal. Kumaravadivelu (2001, p. 545) stresses that “post method pedagogy rejects the narrow view of language education that confines itself to the linguistic functional elements that obtain inside the classroom.” As ELT is an educational activity, relevant content should be added as per the necessity of the country.

Conclusion

The inclusion of local texts, discourse and contents in ELT materials can enhance patriotism by making learners aware of their nation and culture. Learning a foreign language is a right of learners, whereas being patriotic is a duty of a responsible citizen. The results show that Nepal-based contents should be prioritized for enhancing patriotism in Nepali learners in general and Nepali English language learners in particular. As the contents are significant rather than who has written the texts and where the texts have been written. However, it is also true that the texts produced in one’s context and culture are more comprehensible, readable, and learnable for the learners. Furthermore, the results of this study also indicate that the texts written by Nepali English authors should be included in school and university level English courses which help to strengthen patriotism to a greater extent.

The author: Mr. Bhan Singh Dhami is an M. Ed. fourth semester student of Kailali Multiple Campus, Dhangadhi, Kailali under Tribhuvan University of Nepal. He has been teaching since 2006 AD. Currently, he is a secondary level English teacher at Shree Khare Secondary School Gaurishankar RM -8, Dolakha. His areas of interest are academic writing, creative writing, English Language Teaching (ELT), learner autonomy, teacher identity and teacher professional development.  

References

Bar-Tal, D. & Staub, E. (1997). Patriotism: Its scope and meaning. Retrieved from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259389114

Bhandari, B. (2016). Teaching English in Multilingual and Multicultural Contexts in Nepal. Tribhuvan University Journal, 30(2), 17-24. https://doi.org/10.3126/tuj.v30i2.25542

Giri, R. A. (2020). English is one of the local languages in Nepal. https://eltchoutari.com/2020/10/english-is-one-of-the-local-languages-in-nepal-dr-giri/

Giri, R.A. (2015). The many faces of English in Nepal. Asian Englishes, 17:2, 94-115, DOI: 10.1080/13488678.2015.1003452

Karsten, G. E. (1908). Folklore and Patriotism. The journal of English and Germanic philology Vol. 7 (2), pp. 61-78 Published by: University of Illinois Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.com/stable/27699914.

Kodelja, Z. (2019).  Education and Patriotism. In: Sardoč, M. (ed.), Handbook of patriotism, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-30534-9_19-1

Kumaravadivelu (2001). Toward a Postmethod Pedagogy. TESOL quarterly Vol. 35 (4) winter.

Marginson, S. & Dang, T. K. A. (2017). Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory in the context of globalization. Asia Pacific journal of education, 37:1, 116-129, https://doi.org/10.1080/02188791.2016.1216827

Nussbaum, M. C. (2013). Political emotions: why love matters for justice. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA

Saud, M. S. (2020). Rethinking authenticity in ELT texts and materials: A perspective of an author. https://eltchoutari.com/2020/10/rethinking-authenticity-in-elt-texts-and-materials-a-perspective-of-an-author/

Saud, U. (2020). Undermining of “local” in new English textbook for Grade XI. https://eltchoutari.com/2020/10/undermining-of-local-in-new-english-textbook-for-grade-xi/

Ward, S. J. A. (2017). Patriotism and Journalism. In: Sardoč, M. (ed.), Handbook of patriotism, DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-30534-9_39-1

Can be cited as:  Dhami, B. S. [2021, May]. Enhancing patriotism through English language teaching and learning in Nepal. ELT CHOUTARI. Available at: https://eltchoutari.com/2021/04/enhancing-patriotism-through-the-local-contents-in-elt-materials/

This is how mentoring worked for me

135615_1766463684896_7952262_o (1)
Bal Krishna Sharma,   PhD Scholar   University of Hawaii, Manoa, USA

I went to pursue my graduate studies at the University of Hawaii in 2008. Since I was in a new academic environment, any academic help extended to me would be tremendously helpful. I first had little idea on how the US academic system would work, for example, choosing academic advisers, completing assignments, presenting at conferences, finding and using scholarly resources and connecting to the local ELT professional venues. Thanks to the East-West Center, my scholarship sponsor organization, that connected me to an experienced and very helpful mentor, Elaina. Also thanks to the Second Language Studies Students’ Association that provided me an opportunity to work as a mentor for a BA student. In the following sections, I will briefly describe my experience and learning opportunities from these mentoring programs.

Being a Mentee

The East-West Center Alumni Association asked me to fill out a mentoring form providing details of my academic and professional background, academic interest and my expectations from my mentor. However, I had little idea regarding how this would work and help with my graduate studies at the university. I thought at least I would have an opportunity to connect to an ‘American’ professor. The alumni association also asked the potential mentors to fill out similar forms. By matching common interests between the two parties, I was assigned to a mentor at a local community college. I was excited. I wrote my mentor an introductory email and told her that I was her mentee and wanted to know who she was. Elaina took me to an Indian restaurant for dinner for our first meeting. We chatted about our personal and academic interests, family background and future goals. Continue reading This is how mentoring worked for me →