English Teachers’ Practices in Teaching Writing Skills at the Secondary Level: A Study of Community Schools in Rolpa District

          Chandra Prakash Oli

Abstract

This brief study explored the perceptions and classroom practices of secondary English teachers in teaching writing skills in public schools. Using a qualitative approach, I purposively selected four in-service English teachers from four public schools in Rolpa district. Data were collected through unstructured interviews and classroom observations. The findings reveal that teachers hold a positive view of writing instruction and actively apply key strategies—such as controlled, guided, and free writing, alongside process and genre-based approaches—in their classrooms. They perceive they invest their effort to make the teaching of writing as effective as possible, however, classroom realities reveal a significant disconnect between their beliefs and actual practices.

Introduction

Second language learning encompasses four primary skills: listening, speaking, reading, and writing. The development of second language acquisition primarily begins with listening, as it is the first receptive skill to develop in human beings (Renukadevi, 2014). At the initial stage of the second language learning process, learners listen to the target language and gradually learn to read and write, progressing from the English alphabet to words and complete sentences.

To understand the nature of writing, it is necessary to examine the taxonomy of writing. According to Jacobs et al. (1981) and Hall (1988), this taxonomy includes mechanics (spelling and punctuation), vocabulary, grammar, syntax, organization, cohesion, coherence, content, and diction (word selection), all of which must be appropriate to the audience, topic, and occasion. Fundamentally, letters are combined to form words, and words are arranged to form sentences. These sentences are then grouped into paragraphs to develop coherent ideas, making paragraphs the expanded structural units of sentences.

Byrne (1988) asserts that writing is not merely the production of graphic symbols. Similarly, Nunan (2003) highlights that while writing is a physical representation of words and symbols, it is equally a product of the mind. Consequently, multiple cognitive and linguistic elements must be consciously coordinated to produce an effective piece of writing. Because English language teachers hold varying beliefs that shape their instructional decisions, this study explores how teachers’ perceptions and classroom practices are interrelated. Such an inquiry may also encourage teachers to critically reflect upon and improve their pedagogical practices in teaching writing skills.

In the context of Nepal, writing serves as a vital tool for higher education—both domestically and abroad—as well as for occupational and social success. Writing proficiency is particularly critical for secondary-level learners, as their academic grades are largely determined by their performance on written tests and assignments (Graham, 2006). Following the Secondary Education Examination (SEE), students transition into higher studies, where their academic trajectories often depend on their writing competence, particularly in securing admission through competitive entrance examinations. Furthermore, strong writing skills help students obtain full-time or part-time employment in schools and offices to support their livelihood during higher education. Navigating today’s competitive job market requires drafting effective job applications, while professional and academic growth demands proficiency in writing news reports and essays.

However, one of the most significant challenges in teaching writing at the secondary level in Nepal is the persistent dominance of examination-oriented, product-based writing instruction, which is often disconnected from students’ actual communicative needs and foundational English proficiency. Karki (2019), in his study of secondary-level English teachers in public and private schools in Sunsari, found that most teachers predominantly adopted the product approach to writing, emphasizing examination performance and the reproduction of model texts rather than engaging students in the processes of planning, drafting, revising and editing. The study identified several interconnected constraints, including large class sizes, pressure to complete the prescribed syllabus, learners’ low English proficiency, and inadequate instructional materials, teacher training and ICT facilities. Similarly, Sherma (2024) argues that writing instruction in Nepal tends to privilege rigid linguistic rules and examination requirements over writing for specific purposes, audiences and authentic communication. This examination-driven orientation becomes particularly problematic for learners with limited vocabulary, grammatical knowledge and sentence-construction skills, who often struggle to express their own ideas independently. Consequently, writing lessons may become exercises in memorising model compositions and reproducing expected answers rather than developing students’ creativity, critical thinking and communicative competence. The fundamental challenge, therefore, is not simply students’ weak English proficiency but the interaction between their linguistic limitations and a pedagogical and assessment culture that provides insufficient opportunities for meaningful, process-oriented writing.

Thus, developing robust writing skills is essential for secondary learners. Against this backdrop, this study explores teachers’ perceptions, pedagogical practices, and challenges they face in teaching writing.

Product Approach to Writing

A product approach to writing is a conventional methodology in which students are encouraged to mimic a model text that is typically supplied and analyzed at an early stage of instruction (Gabrielatos, 2002). Similarly, Badger and White (2000) assert that the product-based approach views writing as learning linguistic structures and improving proficiency through the imitation of teacher-provided texts. For instance, in a product-based writing classroom, students are given a standard sample text and asked to follow its structural pattern to construct a new piece of writing.

Process Approach to Writing

The process approach emerged in response to the limitations of the traditional product-based model of teaching writing. Flower (1989) notes that process writing developed as a reaction against conventional product-oriented instruction, allowing students to compose naturally, much like writing in their first language. Consistent with Flower’s perspective, this approach gives learners the opportunity to develop ideas organically in their second language rather than relying solely on rigid imitation. It guides students through recursive stages of composition, including pre-writing activities, drafting, revising, receiving and incorporating feedback, editing, and finally sharing their finished work.

Result and Discussion

Teachers’ Preparedness for Teaching Writing

Effective writing instruction requires thorough teacher preparation to ensure meaningful learning takes place (Cicek, 2013). Cicek notes that a daily lesson plan serves as a written account of what a teacher intends to accomplish during a specific lesson or class period. However, the teacher participants reported that they do not prepare written lesson plans due to several barriers: a lack of time and interest, low teacher motivation, perceived costs, and an absence of administrative support. Consequently, the findings reveal that none of the participants routinely prepared for daily lessons. Sima and Rajendra explained that time constraints prevented them from planning, as they balanced multiple responsibilities at school. Furthermore, all three teachers noted that preparing lesson plans is costly and unsupported by the school administration. Sima shared: “Sir, being an English teacher at this school, I have several other responsibilities. I have to conduct assemblies and run other extra-curricular and co-curricular activities. Because of that, I cannot prepare a lesson plan, though I want to prepare.” Similarly, Nitesh expressed regret: “I want to prepare a lesson plan. But sometimes we need money to buy materials. The head-teacher doesn’t help with such things, but also I prepare whenever I am free. I spend my money, sir.” The teachers also reported that lesson planning is not practiced school-wide, and those who attempt it face discouragement from colleagues without any institutional reward. Nitesh added: “Here in this school no teachers make lesson plans. If we make and do some extra labour we get nothing from anyone. Every teacher gets the same salary. Why should someone work for an extra hour, sir?”

Reflecting on these insights, I agree with Kiuhara et al. (2009), who argue that if teachers are to believe that planning fosters students’ writing development and delivers effective instruction, they must receive proper preparation for teaching writing. Comprehensive lesson planning should incorporate clear concepts or objectives, appropriate time blocks, procedural steps, and necessary instructional materials.

Teachers’ Practices in Teaching Writing 

The participant teachers employed distinct strategies to teach writing in their classrooms. Rajesh utilized controlled or parallel practice to teach film reviews; Rajendra applied a guided strategy for story writing; Nitesh engaged students in process-based writing; and Sima relied on the lecture or grammar-translation method for essay writing. Overall, Rajesh and Rajendra drew on product-based approaches, Naresh utilized a process-based approach, and Sima implemented the grammar-translation and lecture methods.

Controlled or parallel writing. The following is the classroom observation of Rajesh, who was teaching film review writing to a class of 30 grade-nine students. The classroom was bright and well-ventilated, with all four walls covered in chart papers from various subjects. Upon entering, Rajesh greeted his students and established a learning rapport by asking about their weekend activities. He then announced that he wanted to share a review of a movie he had watched over the weekend, asking two student volunteers to help paste a chart paper on the board.

In observing this practice, I noted that the teacher utilized a controlled or parallel strategy to teach film review writing. He presented a sample review that he had purposefully composed for the lesson, illustrating the principle that providing strong models is vital for guiding student imitation in the classroom.

Guided writing practice. I observed Rajendra’s grade-ten class, which comprised 13 girls and 9 boys. The classroom was spacious, with three students sharing a bench, though the back benches remained empty. A clock was mounted at the front just above the whiteboard. As Rajendra entered, the class stood up to offer traditional greetings. He then wrote the following prompt on the board: “Two goats → narrow bridge → come from two opposite directions→ both want to pass at the same time → both reach at the middle of the bridge → say “Let me go first!” → both get angry and fight → both fall into the river → moral.”

In this lesson, the teacher employed a guided strategy to teach short story writing. He began by discussing the fundamental elements of a short story before presenting a model sample.

Freewriting. Freewriting is another important strategy for developing student writing skills in schools, offering an innovative approach where students write spontaneously. Harmer (2007) asserts that freewriting provides powerful motivation, helping learners discover the right words to express their personal experiences.

An observation of Sima’s class revealed the following dynamic: she wrote “free writing” on the board and asked students, “What’s an essay? Have you written essays?” After the students responded affirmatively, she wrote the core structural elements—introduction, body, and conclusion—on the board. However, after observing the session, I noted that the teacher lacked a clear application of freewriting in a writing class. Instead of true freewriting, she wrote general essay headings on the whiteboard and assigned the students to write freely on the topic.

Process-based approach to writing. The process-based approach to writing involves distinct instructional stages: pre-writing, drafting, and rewriting or editing. These phases encompass conceptualizing topics, selecting relevant information and ideas, and guiding students through structural frameworks. Naresh attempted to implement a process approach while teaching essay writing.

I observed his class under challenging physical conditions: it was extremely cold outside, and the classroom was dark because all windows were closed tightly. A single ceiling bulb provided illumination, while the four walls were worn and covered in messy markings in chalk and marker. A whiteboard hung on the front wall, surmounted by a clock that displayed incorrect time. Twenty-six students were present. All students stood up to greet Naresh, who returned the greeting and instructed them to sit. He wrote “Essay writing” on the board, directed students to open their books to a specific page, and read aloud the essay titled “My First Visit to Zoo.” Following this reading, he instructed students to write an essay, writing the word “Brainstorming” on the board. Students provided different ideas and different stories of their visit to zoo. Teachers noted down the all different ideas of students. Then he made them select the ideas to include in the essay and also briefed about the language to be used in the essay. Students made the first rough draft. In the second day, students worked in pair to provide feedback to their peers. This way Naresh continued his lesson.

Reflecting on this classroom practice, I observed that Naresh made a sincere effort to implement a process-based approach. While he understood the conceptual framework, the lesson fell short of being fully effective for all learners. The students appeared puzzled because the expectations for each specific stage were unclear. During the observation, I realized that students required explicit instruction and guided practice particularly during the pre-writing brainstorming phase. Hedge (2001) notes that during this stage, students generate ideas and formulate writing plans. To achieve better learning outcomes, the teacher could have encouraged students to collaborate with peers during brainstorming, alongside providing clearer conceptual guidance on drafting and editing.

Conclusion

This study explored secondary English teachers’ perceptions and classroom practices regarding writing instruction in public schools in Nepal. While teachers recognize writing as an essential communicative skill and believe they implement effective, evidence-based process and product approaches, classroom realities reveal a significant disconnect between their beliefs and actual practices.

In practice, writing instruction remains largely unplanned and surface-level. Teachers rarely prepare daily lesson plans, provide sufficient model texts, foster peer collaboration, or offer constructive feedback—often ending lessons without students producing independent writing. This gap is compounded by systemic and pedagogical barriers, including time constraints, large class sizes, limited resources, diverse student backgrounds, and a lack of practical training in implementing writing strategies. Ultimately, the challenge does not lie in teachers’ conceptual understanding of writing instruction, but in their classroom execution. To bridge this gap between belief and practice, secondary English teachers require targeted professional development, institutional support for lesson planning, and practical training in scaffolding collaborative, process-oriented writing activities.

The author: Chandra Prakash Oli holds MPhil from a Nepali university. Mr. Oli serves as a Lecturer and Assistant Campus Chief at Yerawati Adarsha Multiple Campus in Dang, Nepal, where he also coordinates the M.Ed. program and the Research Management Cell (RMC).

References

Badger, R., & White, G. (2000). A process genre approach to teaching writing. ELT Journal, 54(2), 153–160. https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/54.2.153

Byrne, D. (1988). Teaching writing skills (New ed.). Longman.

Cicek, V. (2013). Effective use of lesson plans to enhance education in U.S. and Turkish kindergarten thru 12th grade public school system: A comparative study. International Journal of Teaching and Education, 1(2), 10–20.

Flower, L. (1989). Cognition, context, and theory building. College Composition and Communication, 40(3), 282–311. https://doi.org/10.2307/357775

Gabrielatos, C. (2002). EFL writing: Product and process. ERIC. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED476839

Graham, S. (2006). Strategy instruction and the teaching of writing: A meta-analysis. In C. A. MacArthur, S. Graham, & J. Fitzgerald (Eds.), Handbook of writing research (pp. 187–207). Guilford Press.

Hall, C. (1988). Managing the complexity of revising across languages. TESOL Quarterly, 24(1), 43–60. (Note: Please verify if you used a different 1988 work by Hall).

Harmer, J. (2007). The practice of English language teaching (4th ed.). Pearson Longman.

Hedge, T. (2001). Teaching and learning in the language classroom. Oxford University Press. (Note: The first edition was published in 2000; keep 2001 if citing the specific reprint you used).

Jacobs, H. L., Zinkgraf, S. A., Wormuth, D. R., Hartfiel, V. F., & Hughey, J. B. (1981). Testing ESL composition: A practical approach. Newbury House.

Karki, T. (2019). Writing instruction in secondary schools: Unraveling practices and challenges. Journal of NELTA Gandaki, 1, 108–118. https://doi.org/10.3126/jong.v1i0.24465

Kiuhara, S. A., Graham, S., & Hawken, L. S. (2009). Teaching writing to high school students: A national survey. Journal of Educational Psychology, 101(1), 136–160. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013097

Nunan, D. (2003). Practical English language teaching. McGraw-Hill.

Renukadevi, D. (2014). The role of listening in language acquisition: The challenges & strategies in teaching listening. International Journal of Education and Information Studies, 4(1), 59–63.

Sherma, A. B. (2024). Writing for specific audiences: A comparative study of teaching writing in Nepal and the U.S. ELE Praxis, 1(1), 24–35. https://doi.org/10.51474/elepraxis.v1i1.551

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *